Supreme Court Gives Petitioner One Week to File Rejoinder in Challenge to Jantar Mantar Protest Site De-Notification

The Supreme Court on Friday granted a woman one week to file a rejoinder in her petition challenging the Delhi Police’s decision to remove Jantar Mantar from the list of designated protest sites in the national capital.

A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana adjourned the matter after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta raised objections to certain factual statements in the petitioner’s written submissions.

The petition, filed by Swaty Singh, challenges an October 11 standing order issued by Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar, which de-notified Jantar Mantar as a protest venue and designated three alternative locations: Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in east Delhi.

Court Seeks Affidavit to Support Factual Claims

During Friday’s proceedings, Mehta questioned the factual basis of certain assertions circulated on behalf of the petitioner.

Senior advocate Mukta Gupta, representing Singh, submitted that the written submissions primarily addressed legal propositions and judicial precedents rather than disputed facts.

The bench clarified that any factual claim placed before the court must be supported by an affidavit to establish responsibility for its accuracy.

READ ALSO  SC's AI panel has identified its use to keep track of pending cases: Govt

Mehta also submitted that the rejoinder should be filed on affidavit so that the statements made before the court could be properly attributed to the person making them.

The Solicitor General informed the bench that a request for adjournment had initially been circulated on behalf of Additional Solicitor General S V Raju because of his unavailability, but the letter was subsequently withdrawn.

Petition Questions Effectiveness of Alternative Protest Venues

The petitioner has argued that shifting demonstrations away from Jantar Mantar to distant locations could undermine the constitutional rights to peaceful assembly and freedom of expression.

According to the plea, the right to protest extends beyond the ability to gather at a particular location. It also includes effectively communicating grievances, expressing dissent and bringing public concerns to the attention of authorities.

The petition maintains that the accessibility, visibility and proximity of a protest venue to the institutions concerned are significant factors in determining whether a demonstration can achieve its intended purpose.

READ ALSO  Supreme Court Postpones Andhra Pradesh's Appeal Against CM Chandrababu Naidu's Bail to January 2025

It further challenges the October 11 order as arbitrary and procedurally deficient, arguing that merely identifying alternative locations does not adequately safeguard the right to protest when arrangements governing access to those venues remain subject to a future standard operating procedure.

Supreme Court Had Earlier Sought Government’s Response

On October 15, the Supreme Court issued notices to the Centre and Delhi Police seeking their responses to Singh’s public interest litigation.

During that hearing, the bench indicated that it would examine whether the authorities had adequately considered the utility and effectiveness of Jantar Mantar as a designated protest location before withdrawing its status.

READ ALSO  Can a Person be detained without providing him reasons?

Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for a litigant, sought restoration of the notification recognising Jantar Mantar as a protest site. He pointed out that the de-notification had been described as being in accordance with an earlier Supreme Court order.

Mehta clarified that the previous Supreme Court decision had not formed the basis of the fresh de-notification. He informed the court that a committee constituted to examine the issue had submitted a report setting out the reasons for the decision.

The matter will now be heard after one week, with the petitioner permitted to place her rejoinder on record.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles