Writ Against CARA’s Refusal Of NOC Is Maintainable In Delhi Even If Adoption And Passport Application Took Place In Amritsar: Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court has held that it has territorial jurisdiction to hear a petition seeking directions to the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) to issue a No Objection Certificate (NOC) for an adopted child to relocate abroad. This holds even though the adoption, the birth records and the passport application were all handled in Amritsar. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma rejected the preliminary objection raised by the Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer, Amritsar. The Court found that the principal relief was against CARA, a body located in New Delhi, and that its decision was taken in New Delhi.

Background

Petitioner Harpreet Kaur and her husband are persons of Indian origin who are now Australian citizens and hold OCI cards. They adopted a girl born in Amritsar in 2019. The adoptive mother is a first cousin of the child’s biological father. The adoption was performed according to Sikh rites in October 2021, and a Deed of Adoption under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (HAMA) was registered in Amritsar in November 2021. A fresh birth certificate was issued, and in January 2024 a civil court in Amritsar declared the child to be their adopted daughter.

The couple applied for the child’s passport in Amritsar in January 2022. According to them, the passport authorities would not proceed without an NOC from CARA. In August 2022, CARA wrote from New Delhi asking them to follow Regulation 22C of the Adoption (Amendment) Regulations, 2021, which requires the receiving country to sponsor the case. The couple said the Australian authorities declined to do this. Their representation to CARA in March 2026, asking for the case to be placed before its Relaxation Committee, went unanswered. They then approached the High Court.

READ ALSO  Arya Samaj Marriage Certificate Not Proof of Valid Hindu Marriage, Saptapadi and Other Rituals Necessary: Allahabad High Court 

Arguments

Advocates Piyush Beriwal, Ruchita Srivastava and Sparsh Jain appeared for the Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer, Amritsar. Counsel for these respondents argued that all the material events, from the adoption deed to the passport application, took place in Amritsar. They submitted that the mere presence of Central Government ministries in Delhi does not give the Court jurisdiction. They relied on Oil and Natural Gas Commission v. Utpal Kumar Basu, Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India and Chintan Agrawal v. Union of India, and also invoked the doctrine of forum conveniens.

Advocates Sheenam Chhabra, Anjani Chhabra and Nibha Gupta appeared for the petitioners. They argued that the principal relief was sought against CARA, which has its office in R.K. Puram, New Delhi, and that its refusal to issue the NOC was the integral part of the cause of action. Applying a “but-for” test, they submitted that the passport was held up only because the NOC was missing. They also pointed out that CARA itself had raised no objection to jurisdiction. Advocate V.N. Raghupathy and others appeared for CARA, which has opposed the petition on merits.

READ ALSO  दिल्ली हाईकोर्ट  ने टाटा संस की नकल करने वाली फर्जी वेबसाइट को बंद करने का आदेश दिया

CARA’s decision taken in New Delhi

The Court noted that a High Court may issue writs either where the authority is located, under clause (1) of Article 226, or where the cause of action arises wholly or in part, under clause (2). It added that “the existence of jurisdiction is distinct from its exercise.”

The Court found that CARA’s 2022 communication was issued from New Delhi. The 2026 representation was addressed to CARA in New Delhi and remains undecided. CARA’s stand that it cannot issue the NOC without the receiving country’s approval is a decision taken and maintained in New Delhi. The Court held that “a material and integral part of the cause of action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court, which clearly attracts clause (2) of Article 226 of the Constitution.”

Amritsar facts only background

On the respondents’ objection, the Court said that the adoption deed, the birth records and the civil court decree are not under challenge. It observed that “These facts merely form the background in which the petitioners have sought the NOC from CARA”.

The Court noted that the Regional Passport Office itself had stated that no passport application was pending and that a fresh one would be processed in accordance with law. It held that the relief against the passport office is consequential. It said that “the location of respondent no. 5 at Amritsar cannot take away the jurisdiction of this Court in respect of the principal relief sought against CARA.”

The Court distinguished Chintan Agrawal, where no authority located in Delhi had any role in the decision under challenge, and Dr. Neha Chandra, where the integral facts arose outside Delhi.

No ground to invoke forum conveniens

The Court declined to invoke forum conveniens. It noted that CARA keeps the records in New Delhi, and that Coordinate Benches had decided similar petitions by adoptive parents whose adoption deeds were executed in Punjab and Rajasthan. Pointing out that the child’s relocation has remained pending for nearly five years, the Court said that “Relegating the petitioners to another forum at this stage would neither advance the cause of justice nor subserve the best interests of the child, which must remain a paramount consideration in matters of this nature.”

Outcome

The preliminary objection on territorial jurisdiction was rejected. The Court clarified that its observations are confined to jurisdiction and are not an opinion on the merits. The petition will be heard on merits on 02.12.2026 before the Roster Bench. The Court also allowed an application to amend the prayer clause, which corrected the respondent numbers.

Case Title: Harpreet Kaur & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.
Case No.: W.P.(C) 4401/2026
Bench: Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma
Date: November 19, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles