Past Misconduct Already Punished Cannot Be Treated as Fresh Misconduct to Impose Another Penalty: Supreme Court Orders Reinstatement of CISF Constable

The Supreme Court has held that misconduct for which an employee has already been punished cannot, by itself, be treated as fresh misconduct to justify another penalty. With this ruling, the Court set aside the removal from service of a Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) constable and ordered his reinstatement with 50% back wages.

A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed the appeals filed by Sumit Kumar. The Bench set aside the Delhi High Court’s judgment of February 14, 2024, which had upheld his removal, and its order of July 12, 2024 dismissing his review petition.

Background

Kumar joined the CISF as a Constable (General Duty) in 2012 and was posted at the CISF Unit, Uranium Corporation of India Limited (UCIL), Jaduguda. In October 2017, he took casual leave to look after his wife, who had developed serious complications during pregnancy and underwent surgery. His leave was extended until December 3, 2017, with an intimation that no further extension would be granted.

He rejoined duty on December 3 and sought 12 more days of leave, but his request was declined. On December 6, 2017, saying he was under acute mental stress because of his wife’s condition, he submitted his resignation through the grievance portal. The resignation was closed, and he was granted 12 days of leave the same day.

READ ALSO  Maharashtra granted time to file reply on bail plea of Surendra Gadling in Surajgarh arson case

After he was transferred to the CISF Unit at Heavy Water Plant, Manuguru, he was served a charge memorandum on the day he joined, January 18, 2018. The three charges were:

  • He did not appear before the Commandant on December 6, 2017 and submitted a “conditional resignation” to pressure the administration.
  • He tried to intimidate officials through relatives and made a video of his wife go viral.
  • Despite five earlier minor penalties, he had not mended his ways.

The Inquiry Officer held all three charges proved. On May 1, 2018, the disciplinary authority removed him from service. His departmental appeal and revision were dismissed.

The Delhi High Court called him a habitual offender, observing that “a blot is a blot, be it of the slightest degree.” It held that removal from service was commensurate with his conduct.

Arguments

Counsel for the appellant argued that the penalty was grossly disproportionate and that the charges disclosed no grave or deliberate misconduct. Counsel submitted that the appellant was given no written direction to appear on December 6. He did not have printed medical documents at the time, and he had no knowledge of the video.

Counsel contended that relying on the five earlier penalties amounted to double jeopardy. Counsel further pointed out that Hindi translations of the documents were supplied only after the prosecution witnesses had been examined, and that a defence assistant was denied.

READ ALSO  नाबालिग की सहमति बलात्कार के मामले में कोई मायने नहीं रखती: सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने दोषसिद्धि बरकरार रखी

Counsel for the respondents submitted that the inquiry was held in accordance with the CISF Rules, 2001. In their submission, the appellant had tried to derail the proceedings with repeated applications, and his past record was rightly considered.

Court’s Findings

On the first charge, the Court found no specific written direction in the charge memorandum and no contemporaneous material establishing the alleged communication. It held that, without other reliable evidence, “the charge of deliberate disobedience cannot be sustained merely on the basis of the allegation.”

On the second charge, the Court noted that, according to the evidence of PW-1, the video had come from a different mobile number. The Court also noted that Kumar was at his unit while the video was recorded at the hospital. The Bench held, “The Appellant cannot be held responsible merely by reason of his relationship with the persons alleged to have engaged in such conduct.”

On the third charge, the Court observed, “The previous misconduct for which an employee has already been subjected to disciplinary action cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct for the purpose of imposing another penalty.” It added that a past record may be considered while deciding the penalty for misconduct that has been independently proved, but “It cannot, however, be used to supply the deficiency in proof of the charges in the present proceedings.”

The Bench also found procedural irregularities in the inquiry. It held that supplying Hindi translations at such a late stage “deprived the Appellant of an effective opportunity to understand the material relied upon against him and to prepare his defence.” It added that the denial of a defence assistant, despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, also assumed significance.

READ ALSO  Cheque Issued As Security Would Mature For Presentation On Default When Payment Is Due: Kerala HC

The Court held that even if the conditional resignation was taken as proved, it could not be separated from his wife’s serious medical condition. Citing Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India, the Bench found the penalty “shockingly disproportionate”.

Outcome

The Supreme Court quashed the removal order dated May 1, 2018, along with the appellate and revisional orders. Considering the passage of time, it declined to send the matter back for a fresh inquiry. The Court directed that Kumar be reinstated forthwith with all consequential benefits and 50% of his back wages from the date of removal until reinstatement.

Case Title: Sumit Kumar v. Union of India & Ors.

Case No.: Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 28027-28028 of 2024

Bench: Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh

Date: November 16, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles