Calcutta High Court Initiates Criminal Contempt Proceedings Against TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee Over Remarks on Judge

The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday initiated criminal contempt proceedings against Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee for allegedly accusing a judge of acting under political pressure from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) while hearing his petition concerning the withdrawal of Z+ security cover.

Justice Krishna Rao directed the issuance of a show-cause notice to Banerjee within 15 days, seeking an explanation for statements he allegedly made during a live interview about the Court’s handling of his pending security plea.

In a separate order, the Court directed the West Bengal government’s Department of Home and Hill Affairs to convene a review committee meeting within two weeks to reconsider Banerjee’s request for restoration of Z+ security protection.

The Court will hear the matter again on December 8.

Remarks Against Judiciary Lead to Contempt Proceedings

The contempt proceedings arose from allegations Banerjee made during a live interview concerning the listing and hearing of his security petition.

During the November 12 hearing, Additional Advocate General Billwadal Bhattacharyya, representing the State government, brought the interview to the Court’s attention.

According to the submissions, Banerjee alleged that Justice Rao had deliberately avoided hearing his urgent petition before the High Court’s annual vacation because of political pressure.

He reportedly claimed that his case was listed at serial number 16 on the final working day before the vacation, but the judge heard only 15 matters before concluding the day’s proceedings.

READ ALSO  Police files charge sheet against Lawyer of HC in forgery/cheating case

Banerjee also allegedly accused a section of the judiciary of having political affiliations with the BJP and failing to uphold constitutional principles.

Bhattacharyya submitted that the statements constituted criminal contempt because they questioned judicial impartiality and could prejudice proceedings that remained pending before the Court.

Responding to the allegations during the November 12 hearing, Justice Rao questioned the basis of Banerjee’s assertions and asked his counsel to obtain a list of judges allegedly associated with the BJP and TMC.

Banerjee’s counsel maintained that the statements arose from frustration over continuing threats to the MP and his family. He submitted that Banerjee had experienced multiple attacks and remained concerned about inadequate security arrangements.

Following consideration of the remarks, the Court initiated criminal contempt proceedings on Tuesday.

Dispute Over Reduction of Security Cover

READ ALSO  Rajasthan High Court Grants Interim Bail to Asaram on Medical Grounds

The underlying litigation concerns the West Bengal government’s decision to reduce Banerjee’s security protection from Z+ to X category after the 2026 Assembly elections.

Banerjee challenged the decision before the High Court, alleging that the authorities had acted without conducting an independent assessment of the threats against him.

He claimed that the reduction was politically motivated and followed the BJP’s assumption of power in West Bengal.

According to his petition, his Z+ security classification had been reaffirmed in 2024 but was subsequently withdrawn without adequate justification.

Banerjee also referred to attacks in which stones, shoes and other objects were allegedly thrown at him, arguing that the reduced protection exposed him to continuing security risks.

His petition sought restoration of Z+ cover and production of the official records relied upon by the authorities while deciding to downgrade his security.

Government Defends Security Review

Opposing the petition, the West Bengal government submitted that security classifications were periodically reassessed according to established procedures and that no individual could demand a particular category of protection as an absolute right.

READ ALSO  Mehrauli Murder: Delhi HC grants Poonawala daytime relief from Solitary confinement

The State informed the Court that Banerjee continued to receive protection from three personal security officers deployed in shifts.

It also pointed out that his residence was covered by the Z+ security arrangements provided to former Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, who resided at the same location.

Additional Solicitor General Dhiraj Kumar Trivedi, appearing for the Central government, submitted that authorities were not obligated to disclose the reasons behind a decision to reduce an individual’s security cover.

At an earlier hearing on October 6, Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, representing Banerjee, argued that a person’s security protection should not be downgraded without prior notice or consultation.

He also contended that a proper assessment of threat perception was necessary before the authorities could reduce an existing security classification.

The High Court has now directed the State authorities to reconsider Banerjee’s request through a review committee, while separately requiring him to explain his remarks concerning the judiciary in the criminal contempt proceedings.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles