The Delhi High Court has permitted two senior citizens living in the United Kingdom and the United States to give evidence through video conferencing in a pending probate case, taking into account their age, difficulties associated with international travel and potential health risks from Delhi’s air pollution.
Justice Vinod Kumar, in an order dated November 6, held that these circumstances were relevant to deciding how the witnesses should be examined. The court found that conducting their examination remotely would also prevent the proceedings from being postponed until their proposed visit to India in February or March 2027.
The court designated the High Commission of India in London and the Consulate General of India in New York as the respective remote locations for recording their evidence.
Health Concerns Raised Over Delhi’s Pollution
The two applicants informed the court that their evidence was expected to be recorded between October 2026 and January 2027, a period when Delhi-NCR ordinarily experiences severe air pollution.
They submitted that prolonged exposure to polluted air could adversely affect their health, particularly because they were elderly and unfamiliar with Delhi’s climatic conditions during those months.
The applicants also cited the inconvenience of travelling internationally to attend court proceedings.
Accepting these considerations, Justice Kumar observed that the applicants’ age, overseas residence and concerns about pollution justified examining whether their evidence could be recorded remotely.
Opposing Party Raises Concerns Over Remote Examination
The application faced objections from the opposing party, who argued that video conferencing could create opportunities for witnesses to receive improper assistance or coaching during their examination.
Concerns were also raised about presenting court records and documents at overseas locations, obtaining signatures on recorded statements and coordinating hearings across different time zones.
The opposing party further contended that the proposed arrangement could delay the probate proceedings.
The High Court, however, found that the Delhi High Court Electronic Evidence and Video Conferencing Rules, 2025 contained sufficient procedural safeguards to address these objections.
The court noted that the Rules include measures to prevent witnesses appearing remotely from being prompted, tutored, influenced or coerced by others.
It also observed that concerns about access to documents could be resolved through strict compliance with the prescribed procedure, which permits relevant documents to be presented to witnesses during cross-examination.
To maintain the integrity of the proceedings, the court emphasised that both applicants must remain visible throughout their examination and that coordinators at the designated remote locations must fulfil their responsibilities under the Rules.
Court Directs Applicants to Share Video Conferencing Costs
Allowing the application, the High Court directed that the evidence be recorded through video conferencing using facilities at the designated Indian diplomatic missions.
The court ordered the applicants to pay a combined fee of Rs 1 lakh for the services of an IT officer responsible for ensuring the availability of the required video conferencing arrangements.
Each applicant will contribute Rs 50,000 towards the fee.
The court concluded that the remote examination would address the applicants’ concerns while avoiding the need to defer their evidence until February or March 2027.
Delhi’s Air Quality Remains Poor
Meanwhile, Delhi recorded an overall air quality index (AQI) of 242, placing it in the ‘poor’ category, amid hazy and chilly weather.
Officials indicated that air quality could deteriorate into the ‘very poor’ category as weakening winds, falling temperatures and morning fog restrict the dispersal of pollutants.
Several monitoring stations had already recorded ‘very poor’ air quality, including NSUT Jaffarpur at 336, ITO at 335, Talkatora Garden at 326, Pusa at 322, NIH Narela at 313 and DTU at 303.
