The Supreme Court on Friday sought an explanation from its Registry over the prolonged delay in listing an appeal filed by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) against anticipatory bail granted to a businessman in a ₹155.21-crore money laundering case. The Court ultimately declined to interfere with the bail order after noting that the trial had already commenced and eight witnesses had been examined.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana questioned why the appeal had not been taken up for an effective hearing despite repeated directions for its listing since September 2023.
The bench expressed concern over the administrative delay, with Justice Bagchi describing it as institutional lethargy. Chief Justice Kant directed the Registry to explain why the case had not been listed in accordance with the Court’s earlier orders.
ED Appeal Remained Pending Despite Repeated Listing Directions
The ED had approached the Supreme Court in May 2023, challenging a January 30, 2023 order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court granting anticipatory bail to businessman Raman Singhal, also known as Raman Singla.
The Supreme Court issued notice on the agency’s appeal in September 2023. Subsequent orders directed that the matter be listed again, including for final hearing or disposal. However, the appeal remained pending without an effective hearing for an extended period.
During Friday’s proceedings, Chief Justice Kant questioned the absence of any effective listing across successive years, from September 2023 through September 2026.
When a lawyer suggested that the delay might have resulted from the unavailability of benches, the Chief Justice rejected that explanation and indicated that benches had been available.
Justice Bagchi also expressed concern over the failure to follow the earlier listing directions.
Money Laundering Case Involves Alleged ₹155.21-Crore Bank Fraud
The underlying prosecution concerns allegations of financial irregularities involving Mahesh Timbers Private Limited.
According to the ED, the company fraudulently enhanced Foreign Letters of Credit (FLCs) and transferred funds obtained through those transactions to Amazon Exports Pte Ltd, a Singapore-based company in which Singhal served as a director.
The agency alleged that the transactions resulted in a loss of ₹155.21 crore to the bank and initiated money laundering proceedings against Singhal and other accused persons.
While granting anticipatory bail in January 2023, the Punjab and Haryana High Court considered that the ED had already filed its prosecution complaint.
The High Court also took note of the agency’s position that Singhal could not be arrested at that stage without a warrant issued by the trial court.
The ED subsequently challenged the bail order before the Supreme Court.
Senior Advocates Exchange Arguments Over Listing Delay
During the hearing, Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave, representing Singhal, expressed surprise that an appeal could remain without an effective hearing for such a prolonged period.
Senior Advocate Zoheb Hossain, appearing for the ED, responded by referring to Dave’s lack of experience working in the Supreme Court Registry.
Dave countered that he had been practising before the Supreme Court since 1990 and maintained that delays of this nature were not ordinarily encountered.
The bench, meanwhile, focused on obtaining an explanation from the Registry regarding the failure to comply with previous listing directions.
Supreme Court Disposes of ED Appeal Without Disturbing Bail
The Court was informed that the money laundering trial had already begun and that eight prosecution witnesses had been examined.
Considering the progress of the proceedings, the bench declined to entertain the ED’s challenge to the anticipatory bail order at this stage and disposed of the appeal.
Hossain requested clarification that the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s bail order should not be relied upon as a precedent in other cases.
Accepting the need for clarification, the Supreme Court stated that the impugned order would neither serve as a precedent nor influence the outcome of the ongoing trial.
The Court’s decision leaves Singhal’s anticipatory bail undisturbed while requiring the Registry to account for the prolonged delay in listing the ED’s appeal.
