The Supreme Court on Thursday directed the Election Commission of India (ECI) and other concerned authorities to investigate allegations that fraudulent Form 7 applications were submitted to remove voters from electoral rolls in Delhi’s Mustafabad area during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise.
A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana observed that the Election Commission’s authority over booth-level agents (BLAs) accused of filing fraudulent objections was limited to blacklisting them.
The Court disposed of a petition filed by Ali Mehdi, who alleged that electoral authorities had failed to act despite complaints about false applications seeking the deletion of voters.
Without expressing any opinion on the allegations, the Bench directed the concerned authorities to verify the information submitted by the petitioner and take necessary remedial measures.
36 of 37 Form 7 Objections Allegedly Found False
The petition alleged that several voters in Mustafabad had been targeted through fabricated Form 7 objections, which are used to seek the deletion of names from electoral rolls.
Mehdi relied on newspaper reports stating that 28 voters against whom deletion applications had been submitted were physically found residing at their registered addresses.
His counsel informed the Court that complaints had been submitted to the ECI and Delhi’s Chief Electoral Officer. Following these representations, the District Election Officer-cum-Returning Officer of East Delhi conducted a verification exercise.
According to the petitioner, the verification revealed that a single booth-level agent had filed 37 Form 7 objections, of which 36 were found to be false.
Counsel submitted that electoral laws require proper verification before removing a voter from the electoral roll and prescribe penal consequences for false declarations.
He also referred to the Supreme Court’s ongoing consideration of issues concerning the SIR exercise in Uttar Pradesh, where allegations of false declarations in Form 7 applications had been raised.
The petitioner contended that despite complaints to the Election Commission and other authorities, no FIR had been registered to investigate the allegedly fraudulent applications.
Election Commission’s Powers Limited to Blacklisting Agents
During the hearing, Chief Justice Surya Kant observed that the Election Commission could blacklist a booth-level agent found responsible for submitting fraudulent applications but had no further control over such agents.
The Bench indicated that the allegations primarily concerned the Election Commission and its agents and that appropriate action could be taken by the authorities.
The Chief Justice emphasised that complaints should specifically identify the booth-level agents allegedly responsible for submitting false applications. This would enable the authorities to examine the complaints and initiate necessary remedial or disciplinary action.
Petitioner Seeks Mandatory Notice Before Voter Deletion
Counsel for Mehdi urged the Court to ensure that electoral authorities did not delete any voter’s name solely on the basis of a Form 7 objection without following the prescribed procedure.
He submitted that notices must be issued to both the objector and the elector whose name was proposed for deletion. The authorities should also verify applications suspected of containing false declarations, he argued.
The petitioner sought appropriate action against those responsible for filing fraudulent objections and requested the Election Commission to examine the complaints.
The Supreme Court, however, declined to entertain the petition further and permitted the petitioner to submit a representation to the ECI.
Disposing of the matter, the Bench directed the concerned authorities to verify the petitioner’s information and take necessary remedial measures without recording any finding on the allegations.
The Court did not issue a specific direction for registration of FIRs or decide the validity of the disputed Form 7 applications.
