Supreme Court judge Justice M.M. Sundresh has highlighted the need for independent arbitration institutions, predictable enforcement of awards and specialised judicial expertise to establish India as a trusted centre for international commercial dispute resolution.
Delivering the keynote address at an international legal symposium in Auckland, New Zealand, Justice Sundresh examined India’s evolving arbitration jurisprudence and the reforms required to strengthen confidence among international businesses.
The symposium, titled “Trade with Trust: Harmonising Dispute Resolution in New Zealand–India Trade,” was organised by the New Zealand Bharat Chamber of Commerce and Industry (NZBCCI) and hosted by the Auckland Business Chamber.
Former Governor-General of New Zealand Sir Anand Satyanand attended as the Guest of Honour. The Indian delegation included Allahabad High Court judges Justice Shekhar B. Saraf and Justice Krishan Pahal, Punjab and Haryana High Court judge Justice Sandeep Moudgil, and Prof. (Dr) Ashutosh Mishra, Registrar of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar National Law University.
The discussions took place against the backdrop of the India–New Zealand Free Trade Agreement (FTA) and the two countries’ objective of expanding bilateral trade in goods and services to approximately NZ$7 billion by 2030.
India’s Changing Approach to International Arbitration
Speaking on “Evolving Jurisprudence of International Arbitration,” Justice Sundresh discussed the development of arbitration from traditional dispute resolution practices to an established mechanism for resolving international commercial disputes.
He referred to the Alabama Claims Arbitration of 1872, the establishment of the Permanent Court of Arbitration, the 1958 New York Convention and the UNCITRAL Model Law as important developments in the evolution of international arbitration.
Examining Indian jurisprudence, he discussed the judiciary’s movement from an interventionist approach towards greater recognition of party autonomy, territoriality and the finality of arbitral awards.
Justice Sundresh referred to Supreme Court decisions including Bhatia International v. Bulk Trading S.A., Bharat Aluminium Co. v. Kaiser Aluminium Technical Services Inc. (BALCO), Enercon (India) Ltd. v. Enercon GmbH and Vijay Karia v. Prysmian Cavi E Sistemi SRL.
He also examined the Constitution Bench judgement in Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd., concerning the limited circumstances in which courts may modify arbitral awards without reassessing their merits.
Justice Sundresh highlighted the increasing participation of Indian parties in proceedings before the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC). According to figures cited during his address, cases involving Indian parties increased from 89 in 2022 to 160 in 2023 and 183 in 2024.
He discussed the Draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2024, including proposals concerning emergency arbitration, technology-enabled proceedings, procedural reforms and greater institutional participation.
The judge also referred to the Mumbai Centre for International Arbitration (MCIA), Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC) and other domestic institutions contributing to India’s arbitration infrastructure.
Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Arbitration Challenges
Justice Sundresh examined the application of arbitration to cross-border investments, mergers and acquisitions, renewable energy, environmental, social and governance obligations, and international insolvency.
He discussed the challenges of reconciling contractual autonomy in arbitration with the collective nature of cross-border insolvency proceedings.
Addressing artificial intelligence and online dispute resolution, he identified potential benefits in document review, translation, evidence management and predictive analysis.
However, he also drew attention to confidentiality, algorithmic bias, transparency, data security and procedural fairness. His address emphasised that technological tools should support arbitrators without replacing their independent judgement.
Justice Shekhar B. Saraf Emphasises Judicial Restraint in Enforcement
Allahabad High Court judge Justice Shekhar B. Saraf addressed the symposium on “Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards: Judicial Restraint and the Rule of Finality.”
Comparing the arbitration frameworks of India and New Zealand, he discussed the New York Convention and Section 48 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
Justice Saraf emphasised that courts must distinguish between enforcing an arbitral award and reconsidering the underlying dispute. He explained that while arbitration derives its authority from the agreement between parties, effective enforcement depends on the courts.
He stressed that courts must safeguard consent, fairness and fundamental public policy without exceeding the limits of their enforcement jurisdiction.
Justice Saraf also highlighted the importance of predictable enforcement mechanisms for maintaining international commercial confidence and supporting sustainable trade relations.
Commercial Courts Must Encourage Early Settlement: Justice Sandeep Moudgil
Punjab and Haryana High Court judge Justice Sandeep Moudgil spoke on the “Role of Commercial Courts in Early Dispute Resolution.”
He discussed the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, particularly Section 12A, which requires pre-institution mediation in commercial suits that do not contemplate urgent interim relief.
Justice Moudgil emphasised that commercial courts should not function solely as adjudicatory bodies but should also promote early settlement through mediation, negotiation and effective case management.
He linked timely dispute resolution with lower litigation costs, preservation of commercial relationships, investor confidence and ease of doing business.
Justice Krishan Pahal Calls for Stronger International Commercial Mediation
Allahabad High Court judge Justice Krishan Pahal delivered an address on “International Commercial Mediation,” highlighting its role in resolving disputes while preserving business relationships.
Drawing upon the Rig Veda, he discussed the importance of dialogue, cooperation and mutual understanding in dispute resolution.
Justice Pahal examined India’s Mediation Act, 2023, developments under the UNCITRAL framework and the Singapore Convention on Mediation.
He proposed greater cooperation between India and New Zealand through institutional partnerships, judicial roundtables, professional exchange programmes and cross-border co-mediation protocols.
His address encouraged greater use of mediation as a preferred mechanism for resolving international commercial disputes.
Prof. Ashutosh Mishra Proposes Institutional Cooperation Plan
Prof. (Dr) Ashutosh Mishra, Registrar of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar National Law University, examined the relationship between bilateral trade, institutional frameworks and effective commercial dispute resolution.
Speaking on “Bilateral Trade Dynamics: Institutional Frameworks and Comparative Dispute Resolution Practices,” he highlighted the importance of legal certainty, procedural predictability and enforcement mechanisms in supporting the India–New Zealand FTA.
He proposed model dispute resolution clauses, stronger cooperation between arbitration institutions and the inclusion of commercial dispute resolution issues in the FTA review agenda.
Prof. Mishra also called for judicial and academic exchanges and suggested a twelve-month cooperation plan involving universities, legal institutions and industry stakeholders.
He emphasised that greater market access must be accompanied by credible legal mechanisms capable of resolving commercial disputes.
Symposium Focuses on Strengthening Bilateral Legal Cooperation
The Auckland gathering also brought together Dr. Madan Mohan Sethi, Consul General of India in Auckland; Judge Dr. Ajit Swaran Singh, who became the first Fijian of Indian heritage appointed as a District Court Judge in New Zealand in 2002; and Mahesh Bindra, Chairman of the NZBCCI.
A special closing address by Simon Bridges, Chief Executive Officer of the Auckland Business Chamber, was also scheduled as part of the programme.
The symposium brought together members of the judiciary, legal academia, diplomatic community and business sector to examine ways of strengthening cooperation in arbitration, mediation and commercial litigation.
The discussions focused on how reliable dispute resolution institutions, judicial cooperation and predictable enforcement could support expanding commercial relations between India and New Zealand.
