The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) in Maharashtra’s Thane district has directed a tanker owner and Shriram General Insurance Company Limited to pay Rs 14.11 lakh in compensation to a homoeopathy doctor who sustained serious injuries after a tanker struck his motorcycle in Mumbai in December 2019.
MACT member R V Mohite held the tanker driver solely responsible for the accident, rejecting the insurance company’s allegation that the injured motorcyclist had contributed to the collision.
In an order passed on Monday, the tribunal directed the vehicle owner and insurer to pay the compensation jointly and severally, along with interest at 9 per cent per annum from the date the claim petition was filed until the amount is realised.
Tribunal Rejects Insurer’s Negligence Allegation
The claim was filed by Mohammad Hanif Wajid Ali Akhtar, a resident of Mankhurd who was 42 years old when the accident occurred.
The insurance company disputed Akhtar’s age, professional status and earnings. It also sought to attribute part of the responsibility for the accident to him.
However, the tribunal found no evidence supporting these objections. It concluded that the tanker driver’s rash and negligent driving had caused the accident and observed that he had the final opportunity to prevent the collision.
The tanker owner did not participate in the proceedings, prompting the tribunal to proceed against him ex parte.
Accident Left Doctor With Severe Leg Injuries
The accident occurred on the afternoon of December 19, 2019, while Akhtar was waiting at a traffic signal on Panvel-Sion Marg in Mumbai.
A speeding tanker approached from behind and struck his motorcycle, throwing him onto the road. The driver continued moving, and the tanker’s front left tyre passed over Akhtar’s right leg.
Akhtar suffered severe injuries and was first admitted to Rajawadi Hospital in Mumbai. He subsequently underwent further treatment at other hospitals.
Following the incident, Mankhurd police registered a criminal case and later filed a charge sheet against the tanker driver.
Income and Functional Disability Considered
While determining compensation, the tribunal referred to Supreme Court principles governing the assessment of permanent disability and its impact on a claimant’s earning capacity.
It assessed Akhtar’s notional monthly income at Rs 20,000, equivalent to Rs 2.40 lakh annually, and considered his functional disability at 12 per cent.
Based on its assessment, the tribunal awarded Rs 14.11 lakh in compensation.
Of the total amount, Rs 3 lakh must be placed in a fixed deposit with a nationalised bank for two years, as directed by the tribunal.
