The Supreme Court has ruled that a party cannot bring in additional evidence at the appellate stage to fill gaps in its case or to set up a new case. On this basis, it refused to accept a 1900 forest notification that the Kerala government had produced for the first time before the top court.
A Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe dismissed the State’s appeal. The appeal had challenged a Kerala High Court ruling that 12 acres of land in Edakkara Village, Malappuram District, is not a private forest and did not vest in the State Government.
Background
The respondents are the legal representatives of Neelakandan Pillai. According to them, in October 1960 the Nilambur Kovilakam leased the land, along with 60 adjoining acres, to Koolimanikkath Dayanandan, who in turn leased it to their father. Neelakandan Pillai grew paddy and tapioca on the land until his death in October 1976. After that, the land passed to the respondents.
In November 1988, Forest Department officials stopped the respondents from farming the land. The respondents then applied to the Forest Tribunal under Section 8 of the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971, asking for a declaration that the land was not a private forest.
The Tribunal first dismissed the application. On appeal, the High Court remanded the case. On remand, the Tribunal held on September 29, 2001, that there was no evidence the land was governed by the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act, 1949 (MPPF Act). It noted that the Commissioner had found only bamboo clusters less than 10 years old and four wells, and it concluded that the land was not a forest on May 10, 1971, the appointed day. The High Court upheld this finding in January 2008.
While the appeal was pending before the Supreme Court, the State filed an application to bring in additional documents. With it, the State produced Notification No. 471 dated October 30, 1900, issued under the Madras Forest Act, 1882. According to the State’s affidavit, the document was traced in 2021 at the Forest Headquarters in Thiruvananthapuram.
Arguments
Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta, for the State, argued that the High Court should have examined whether the land was a private forest under Section 2(f)(1)(ii) of the Act. He submitted that vesting is automatic and needs no notification. He relied on the 1900 notification to show that the land was a private forest and asked for the case to be sent back to the High Court.
Senior Advocate A. Hariprasad, for the respondents, argued that the concurrent findings of fact did not call for interference. He submitted that the notification does not show the land to be a private vested forest. He also pointed out that it had been produced 125 years after it was issued, by which time the land’s topography would have changed beyond recognition.
Court’s Findings
The Court held that vesting under the Act takes place by operation of law. It observed that “The vesting is automatic and does not depend upon the demarcation of boundaries under Section 6 of the Act or the issuance of a notification under Rule 2A of the Rules.” It added, however, that only a “private forest” as defined in Section 2(f) of the Act vests in the Government.
On the burden of proof, the Court said the person claiming that land is not a private forest must prove it, but the standard is preponderance of probabilities. It noted that both the State’s witnesses had admitted there was no document showing the land was governed by the MPPF Act. It held that the Tribunal’s finding, which the High Court upheld, could not be called perverse.
Rejecting the application for additional evidence, the Court stated that “A party cannot be permitted to adduce evidence to fill up the lacunae or to setup a new case.” It pointed out that the State had not produced the notification before the Tribunal on remand or before the High Court, and said that “The explanation offered by the appellants exhibits lack of due diligence.”
The Court also found that the notification contains no description by which the land can be identified. It said there was no material showing that the Kariam Muriam block forest, to which the notification relates according to the State’s affidavit, is contiguous to the land.
Outcome
The Court rejected the State’s application to bring in additional documents and dismissed the appeal, with no order as to costs.
Case Title: State of Kerala & Anr. v. P. Krishna Pillai & Ors.
Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 10198 of 2010
Bench: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe
Date: November 16, 2026
