The Andhra Pradesh High Court has granted anticipatory bail to a police constable accused of establishing a physical relationship with a female colleague on the promise of marriage before refusing to marry her on caste grounds. The court held that a consensual relationship between adults cannot subsequently be treated as rape merely because the relationship ended or the promised marriage did not take place.
Justice Y Lakshmana Rao, in an order dated November 11, observed that sexual intercourse based on a promise of marriage does not automatically constitute rape. For criminal liability to arise on the ground of consent obtained through deception, the prosecution must establish that the promise was false from the beginning and was made without any intention of being fulfilled.
The court found that the material presented did not prima facie establish an offence under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). It also noted that the allegations did not specifically disclose caste-based abuse or assault under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
Court Examines Consent and Promise of Marriage
While considering the anticipatory bail application, the High Court referred to the Supreme Court’s decision in Pramod Suryabhan Pawar, which explained the circumstances in which consent obtained through a promise of marriage may amount to a misconception of fact.
The court observed that consent involves an active and reasoned decision by a woman after considering the nature and consequences of the act. Where a false promise of marriage is alleged, it must be demonstrated that the accused acted in bad faith from the outset and never intended to honour the commitment.
Applying these principles, the court noted that the complainant and the petitioner were both serving police constables, aged 29 and 32 respectively. As adults presumed to possess mental maturity, their relationship had to be examined in light of the circumstances described in the complaint.
The complainant’s own account indicated that the two had developed a romantic relationship and subsequently engaged in physical intimacy. The court considered this significant in assessing whether the relationship was consensual.
It further observed that an adult relationship that later fails because of intervening circumstances cannot retrospectively be characterised as rape or sexual exploitation. The court also cautioned that initiating criminal proceedings merely because a relationship has ended places an additional burden on the judicial system and affects the accused’s reputation.
Complaint Alleged Forced Abortion and Refusal to Marry
According to the prosecution, the two constables became acquainted in 2022 while posted at different police stations within the same district.
The complainant alleged that the petitioner expressed his love for her and promised marriage. She stated that she agreed to physical relations on several occasions because she believed that commitment.
She subsequently became pregnant and alleged that the petitioner compelled her to consume abortion pills, resulting in a miscarriage. Attempts by family elders to arrange their marriage were unsuccessful.
The dispute escalated when the petitioner allegedly telephoned the complainant on her birthday and informed her that he no longer wished to marry her because of caste differences. He then blocked her telephone number.
A few days later, the complainant reportedly discovered photographs on Facebook indicating that the petitioner had become engaged to another woman.
She alleged that when she questioned him, he refused marriage because she belonged to the Scheduled Caste community.
The prosecution further stated that the complainant, distressed by these developments, attempted to take her own life. She was admitted to a hospital, where police recorded her statement and subsequently registered a criminal case.
High Court Grants Pre-Arrest Bail
Following the registration of the case, the petitioner approached the High Court seeking protection from arrest.
The allegations involved sexual intercourse through deceitful means, including a false promise of marriage, causing miscarriage, and offences under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.
After examining the allegations and the legal principles laid down by the Supreme Court, Justice Rao granted anticipatory bail, taking into account the nature and gravity of the accusations.
The High Court concluded that the foundational material did not disclose a prima facie offence under the relevant BNS provisions. It also found that the allegations under the SC/ST Act lacked specific accusations of caste-based abuse or assault.
The ruling reiterated that the failure of a relationship or a promise of marriage, without material showing fraudulent intent from the outset, is insufficient by itself to establish rape.
