The Supreme Court on Friday directed that the suo motu proceedings concerning the proposed relocation of Delhi’s 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library be placed before Chief Justice of India Surya Kant for assignment to an appropriate bench. The Court also continued the Centre’s undertaking that no books would be shifted until further orders.
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva passed the direction after noting that the subject did not fall within its assigned roster. The bench had initiated proceedings on its own after media reports raised concerns about the preservation of approximately 8.5 lakh books during the library’s proposed relocation under the Central Vista redevelopment project.
Court Raises Concern Over Preservation of Rare Books
During the hearing, Justice Kumar expressed concern over photographs showing books stored in poor conditions at RK Puram, where part of the library’s collection has reportedly remained for around 15 years.
The judge emphasised that heritage preservation extends beyond protecting historic buildings and must also include rare books and manuscripts. He referred to material in the library’s collection dating back several centuries, including books from the 1700s, and stressed the importance of safeguarding them.
Justice Kumar also recalled a 2009 fire at the Hyderabad High Court library, which had destroyed valuable historical material. He referred to the emotional response of then Chief Justice A R Dave to the loss of the collection, highlighting the irreplaceable nature of such books.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, agreed with the bench’s concerns. Referring to the destruction of the ancient library at Nalanda, he acknowledged that losing historically significant collections could cause irreversible damage.
Mehta assured the Court that the government recognised the importance of protecting the library’s collection.
Roster Issue Leads to Reference to CJI
Justice Kumar explained that the bench had taken suo motu cognisance of the matter after informing the office of the Chief Justice of India. However, since the subject was outside its current roster, he considered it appropriate to seek administrative assignment by the CJI.
Although Mehta submitted that the Centre had no objection to the same bench continuing with the proceedings, Justice Kumar emphasised the need to follow the established procedure.
The judge also referred to the recent controversy involving the reassignment of certain matters from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah.
The bench indicated that the case could eventually return to it, but made clear that the government must honour its earlier undertaking until an appropriate bench takes up the matter.
It further clarified that any urgent issue could be mentioned before the bench headed by the CJI.
Mehta reaffirmed that the Centre would comply with its undertaking. He also informed the Court that discussions involving the amicus curiae and government officials would be held to find a suitable solution.
Earlier Directions on Library Space
On November 16, the Supreme Court had questioned the Centre’s proposed relocation of the library without adequate arrangements to preserve its approximately 8.5 lakh books.
The bench had expressed concern over the handling and storage of the collection and observed that the authorities appeared to be following an ad hoc approach to heritage conservation.
Earlier, on October 5, the Court had sought the actual layout plan and details of the space proposed for the library under the Central Vista redevelopment project.
The government had informed the Court that the library currently occupied approximately 4,144 square metres and would receive around 5,200 square metres at the proposed location.
The bench subsequently sought an affidavit explaining whether the allotted space would be sufficient to accommodate both the books housed at Shastri Bhawan and those stored in cartons at RK Puram, which reportedly had not been opened since 2011.
Uncertainty Over Relocation Under Central Vista Project
The Central Secretariat Library has operated from four floors of Shastri Bhawan since 1969. Its proposed relocation became controversial following reports that only two rooms had been allocated for it at the Kartavya Bhawan-2 complex.
The Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs subsequently clarified that the Central Vista redevelopment plan included space for the library and that the process for constructing its new premises was underway.
Despite that assurance, concerns remained over the proposed accommodation and the preservation of the collection during relocation.
With Friday’s order, the question of which bench will hear the proceedings now rests with the Chief Justice of India. Meanwhile, the Centre remains bound by its November 16 undertaking not to shift the books until further orders.
