The Delhi High Court has held that the mere location of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) headquarters in New Delhi does not give it territorial jurisdiction to examine disputes arising entirely in another state. The Court consequently dismissed a petition concerning the alleged forced religious conversion of Adivasi Christian families in Chhattisgarh.
In a judgement delivered on November 19, Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that the Chhattisgarh High Court was the appropriate forum to examine the grievances, as the alleged incidents and subsequent administrative inaction had occurred in Sukma district.
The petitioner had approached the Delhi High Court challenging the NHRC’s decision to dispose of his complaint by forwarding it to the local district authorities for necessary action.
NHRC’s Location Cannot Determine Jurisdiction
The petitioner argued that since the challenged order had been passed by the NHRC, which maintains its headquarters in Delhi, the Delhi High Court had jurisdiction to hear the matter.
Rejecting this argument, the Court observed that the NHRC receives complaints concerning alleged human rights violations from across India, including complaints submitted online.
Justice Sharma reasoned that accepting the petitioner’s interpretation would effectively allow every NHRC decision concerning an incident anywhere in the country to be challenged before the Delhi High Court solely because the Commission operates from the national capital.
The Court emphasised that the underlying dispute, including the alleged violence, displacement and failure of local authorities to intervene, was connected to Chhattisgarh rather than Delhi.
Allegations of Violence and Displacement
According to the petition, the petitioner and several other Adivasi families from Chitlanar village in Sukma district had practised Christianity peacefully for approximately 18 years while cultivating their ancestral lands.
The families alleged that in March 2026, a mob that included local panchayat members entered their homes and demanded that they convert to Hinduism or leave the village.
The petition claimed that those refusing to comply faced assaults with lathis and death threats. It further alleged that local police personnel failed to intervene despite being present during the incident.
Following the alleged violence, several families, including women, children and elderly persons, were forced to relocate to Sukma town, where they continued to live in temporary shelters, according to the petition.
The petitioner subsequently lodged a complaint with the NHRC under the Protection of Human Rights Act.
Challenge to NHRC’s Disposal of Complaint
In June 2026, the NHRC disposed of the complaint after forwarding it to the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police, Sukma.
The Commission directed the authorities to take appropriate action within eight weeks, involve the complainant or affected families in the process and communicate the action taken to them.
Dissatisfied with the disposal, the petitioner sought directions from the Delhi High Court requiring the NHRC to treat its order as an interim measure rather than a final decision.
He also requested that the Commission reconsider his complaint and provide an opportunity for a hearing before passing any final disposal order.
The central government opposed the petition on jurisdictional grounds. It submitted that the entire cause of action arose in Sukma, where the alleged incidents occurred and where the district administration and police were accused of inaction.
The government maintained that the NHRC’s headquarters in Delhi could not independently establish the High Court’s territorial jurisdiction.
Chhattisgarh High Court Is the Appropriate Forum
The Delhi High Court also noted that the petitioner had not made the Chhattisgarh government, the Sukma District Magistrate or the Superintendent of Police parties to the proceedings, despite directing his allegations of administrative inaction against these authorities.
The Court observed that these were also the authorities responsible for acting upon the NHRC’s directions.
Applying the principles governing territorial jurisdiction and forum conveniens, the Court declined to examine the petition.
It dismissed the petition and any pending applications while granting the petitioner liberty to pursue available legal remedies before the appropriate forum, including the Chhattisgarh High Court.
The decision was confined to jurisdiction and did not determine the merits of the allegations concerning religious conversion, violence or displacement.
