Writ Court Cannot Decide Title Over Public Land; Occupants Must Reply To Eviction Notice Before Collector: Calcutta High Court

The Calcutta High Court has held that a writ court cannot decide a party’s right, title and interest over alleged public land. The Court said that doing so would intrude on the jurisdiction of the Collector under the West Bengal Public Land (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1962.

Justice Partha Sarathi Sen dismissed two connected writ petitions challenging eviction proceedings over land recorded in the name of Habra State General Hospital. The Court gave the occupants liberty to file their show-cause reply before the authority, and protected their possession until a reasoned order is passed.

Background

The petitioners had first approached the High Court against a notice from the SDO, Barasat Sadar Sub-Division, North 24 Parganas. The notice forwarded the minutes of a meeting held on 27.09.2019. The minutes recorded that the petitioners were found to be encroachers of 15 decimals of Government land on Dag No. 332/1965, recorded in the name of Habra State General Hospital. The petitioners were directed to produce documents showing their lawful occupation.

In the second petition, they challenged a notice dated 23.11.2021 under Section 3(1) of the 1962 Act. In it, the SDO, acting as Collector, stated that the land was in their unauthorised occupation. The SDO asked them to show cause why an eviction order under Section 4(1)(a) should not be passed.

As the two petitions were connected and their subject matter was identical, the Court decided them by a common judgment.

READ ALSO  Employee Should Not Be Deprived of Any Benefit Under Law Only Because Some Error Has Been Committed by Employer: Allahabad HC

Arguments

Senior Advocate Prabal Kumar Mukherjee, appearing with Arpan Guha for the petitioners, submitted that his clients were lawful occupiers. He said they had produced all relevant documents of title at the 2019 meeting, but the SDO did not consider them favourably. He argued that the later Section 3(1) notice showed the SDO’s closed mind. He added that sufficient documents of title had also been placed before the High Court, and these had been considered by several Co-ordinate Benches while the petitions were pending.

Advocate Nikunj Berlia, appearing for the State in the 2019 petition, and Advocate Partha Banerjee, appearing for the State in the 2021 petition, argued that both petitions were premature. They said that under Section 3, the Collector may issue a notice once he forms an opinion that public land is in unauthorised occupation. The petitioners, despite being given due opportunity, had failed to substantiate their title. The State also pointed out that the SDO had not tried to evict them without due process, and had only asked them to show cause.

READ ALSO  Application u.s 12 of Domestic Violence Act Is Not A Complaint and Procedure u.s 200-204 CrPC Won’t Apply: Meghalaya HC

Court’s Findings

After examining Sections 2, 3, 4 and 5 of the Act, the Court found that the SDO falls within the definition of “Collector” under Section 2(1). It said Section 3 makes it the Collector’s duty to issue a show-cause notice once he is of the opinion that public land is in unauthorised occupation.

The Court rejected the “closed mind” argument. It held that the SDO’s opinion was “merely tentative in nature”, since otherwise he would not have asked the petitioners to show cause. It found that the SDO committed no legal infirmity or procedural error and was justified in issuing the notice after giving the petitioners an opportunity to substantiate their title.

On the petitioners’ reliance on documents placed before the High Court, the Court observed that “sitting in writ jurisdiction, this Court cannot adjudicate right, title and interest of a party before it since it lacks the machinery to decide such questions.”

It further noted that any such attempt “would tantamount to encroachment to the jurisdiction of the Collector” under the Act. The petitioners, it said, ought to have approached the SDO with their show-cause and supporting documents instead of filing the writ petitions.

READ ALSO  पंचायत चुनाव: कलकत्ता हाईकोर्ट ने एसईसी से 82,000 से अधिक केंद्रीय बलों के कर्मियों को तैनात करने के लिए कहा

Outcome

Finding no merit in the petitions, the Court dismissed both and vacated any interim order. It gave the petitioners liberty to file their reply, with supporting evidence, to the 23.11.2021 notice before respondent no. 4 within fifteen working days.

The authority must then hear the petitioners and pass a reasoned order within thirty working days of receiving the reply. The Court described these time limits as “peremptory and mandatory”, binding on both sides. If the reply is found to lack merit, the authority must take consequential action under Section 4.

Until the reasoned order is passed, the State and its instrumentalities shall not disturb the petitioners’ possession. No order was made as to costs.

Case Title: Debasis Ray & Ors. v. The State of West Bengal & Ors.

Case No.: WPA 21480 of 2019 and WPA 19815 of 2021

Bench: Justice Partha Sarathi Sen

Date: 13.11.2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles