The Supreme Court on Friday refused to consolidate FIRs registered in Gujarat and Haryana against an accused in an alleged investment fraud involving the sale of virtual cloud space, holding that an accused cannot dictate where victims should lodge their complaints.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana declined to grant relief to Bhumi Uptalbhai Patel, who had approached the Court seeking consolidation of criminal cases pending in different states.
The Court emphasised that separate investigations conducted by police authorities in different jurisdictions could not become a ground for granting an advantage to an accused merely because the investigations overlapped.
Accused Cannot Restrict Investigations Across States
During the hearing, Justice Bagchi observed that victims were entitled to approach the police authorities concerned and that an accused could neither determine where complaints should be filed nor prevent police forces in different states from investigating offences within their respective jurisdictions.
The bench also indicated that the question of overlapping investigations was a matter for the investigating agencies to address rather than a basis for directing consolidation at the instance of the accused.
While refusing to combine the FIRs registered in Gujarat and Haryana, the Supreme Court clarified that Patel could approach the respective jurisdictional High Courts to seek appropriate relief regarding the consolidation of cases within each state.
Organised Cybercrime Requires Strict Application of Law
The Court also expressed concern over organised cybercrime and indicated that such offences warranted the strictest application of the law.
Justice Bagchi rejected the suggestion that the petitioner should receive any leniency, observing that the law must be applied with maximum strictness when dealing with organised cybercrimes.
The bench consequently declined to grant any relaxation on the grounds raised in the petition.
Criminal Cases Pending in Gujarat and Haryana
The proceedings arise from allegations of investment fraud connected with the sale of virtual cloud space. Criminal cases against Patel are pending before trial courts in Gandhinagar, Gujarat, and Faridabad, Haryana.
According to the records placed before the Supreme Court, Patel had surrendered, and the relevant custody certificate was submitted to the Court.
The petitioner had spent five months and five days in judicial custody as an undertrial prisoner and was lodged in Central Jail, Ahmedabad.
The Supreme Court ultimately refused to direct the consolidation of the FIRs across the two states, leaving the petitioner free to pursue appropriate remedies before the jurisdictional High Courts.
