Unverified Photocopies Of Alleged Forged Bank Guarantees Cannot Alone Form Basis Of Forgery Prosecution: Allahabad High Court

The Allahabad High Court has held that unverified photocopies of allegedly forged bank guarantees cannot by themselves support a prosecution for forgery. This is especially so when neither the issuing bank nor the department that received the guarantees has alleged any fraud. Justice Chawan Prakash quashed the cheating and forgery proceedings against four directors of M/s S.P.B.L. Energies Pvt. Ltd. The Court said that a business dispute among directors had been drawn into criminal litigation.

Background

The complainant, Rajeev Talreja, said he was a director of M/s M.T.G. Infra Power Ltd. and a commercial director of S.P.B.L. Energies. Under an agreement dated 30.09.2013, government tenders obtained by S.P.B.L. were to be subcontracted to M.T.G. Infra Power. The payments were to go into a jointly operated account. He alleged that the applicants, Somendra Mehta, Romendra Mehta, Sandeep Kumar Garg and Gaurang Garg, diverted funds into unauthorised accounts and paid about ₹50 crore to fictitious suppliers.

He first filed a complaint case in 2018, in which two applicants were summoned on 19.02.2019. He then lodged an FIR in Kanpur Nagar with the same allegations. The FIR added that the applicants had used seven forged bank guarantees to secure tenders from Dakshinanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. (DVVNL), Agra.

READ ALSO  Allahabad HC Extends All Interim Orders till 05.01.2021

The investigation was moved from the local police to the Economic Offences Wing (EOW). The EOW filed a final report on 28.12.2020 saying no case was made out. The Special CJM rejected that report on the complainant’s protest petition. After a revision, the Special CJM summoned the applicants on 23.09.2022 under Sections 406, 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120B IPC. Their discharge application was rejected on 28.04.2025.

Arguments

Senior Counsel Purnendu Chakravarty, assisted by Advocates Kunal Shah, Rohit Kanaujiya and Aryan Singh, appeared for the applicants. He argued that the dispute was essentially civil and had already gone to arbitration. He also submitted that only photocopies of the alleged guarantees were produced, and that the bank officials had told the EOW they never gave the statements attributed to them by the earlier investigating officer.

Senior Counsel G.S. Chaturvedi, assisted by Advocate Alok Ranjan Mishra, appeared for the complainant. He objected that the applicants should have filed a revision under Section 438 BNSS against the order rejecting discharge. He also argued that the local police had found seven guarantees to be forged and that the EOW had ignored this evidence. AGA Jyoti Kumar Singh, assisted by Durgesh Kumar Tripathi, appeared for the State and supported the impugned orders.

Section 528 plea maintainable

Relying on Dhariwal Tobacco Products Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra and Prabhu Chawla v. State of Rajasthan, the Court held that the availability of a revision does not absolutely bar its inherent jurisdiction under Section 528 BNSS. It rejected the preliminary objection.

READ ALSO  HC Convicts Person Who Removed Minor’s Innerwear for Outraging Modesty but Acquits for Attempt to Rape Charge

No forgery or cheating made out on photocopies

The Court noted the bank officials’ statements to the EOW. They said the photocopies could not be verified without the originals, and that the bank had issued guarantees to the firm from time to time against sufficient mortgaged property. It held that “secondary evidence, such as unverified photocopies without any primary report providing forensic or expert validation, cannot form the sole basis for instituting criminal proceedings for serious offences such as those under Sections 467 and 468 of the IPC.”

On Section 420 IPC, the Court found that neither DVVNL nor the bank had complained of any wrongful loss. It observed that “Section 420 is not a net cast wide enough to catch every allegedly false document.”

The Court said that the Magistrate had ignored the EOW statements and summoned the applicants on the informant’s uncorroborated statement and unverified photocopies. It added that “A co-director of a company cannot arbitrarily allege that ‘the company defrauded third parties’ when those third parties themselves explicitly deny any such fraud or illegality.”

Criminal law not a tool in boardroom disputes

Pointing to the arbitration proceedings and the five-year delay in lodging the FIR, the Court held: “The criminal process cannot be permitted to be weaponised as a tool of oppression or vengeance in intra-company disputes.” It concluded that continuing the case “would merely prolong a business-related personal dispute in the guise of serious penal charges.”

Outcome

The Court allowed all three applications. It set aside the orders dated 19.02.2019, 15.03.2022, 23.09.2022 and 28.04.2025, and quashed the entire proceedings in both the complaint case and the FIR case.

Case Title: Gaurang Garg v. State of U.P. and Another (with connected applications)

READ ALSO  Allahabad HC Postpones UPHJS Mains Exam- Know More

Case No.: Application U/S 528 BNSS No. 46499 of 2025 (with Application U/S 482 Nos. 35335 of 2022 and 11879 of 2021)

Bench: Justice Chawan Prakash

Date: November 4, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles