Brother of Complainant Cannot Head Disciplinary Inquiry; Close Kinship Disqualifies Where Reasonable Likelihood of Bias Exists: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has set aside the termination of a Nagpur school teacher. It held that a disciplinary inquiry headed by the real brother of the complainant and key witness is vitiated by a reasonable likelihood of bias, and that the employee does not have to prove any specific instance of bias.

A Bench of Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Manmohan allowed the teacher’s appeal against the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) judgment of 29.04.2025. It restored the School Tribunal’s order directing her reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages.

Background

Kiran Bhujade was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in 2009 at a school run by Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha, Nagpur. After the school received 20% grant-in-aid in 2016, she alleged that the Sanstha’s Secretary, Rajesh Masurkar, left her name out of the salary grant lists. She complained to the authorities in March 2021. A committee set up by the Education Officer found that her name had not been included and directed that it be added.

In the meantime, the management issued her a show cause notice and later a charge-sheet with 20 charges. Prakash Masurkar, the Secretary’s real brother, was made Convenor of the three-member Inquiry Committee. By a 2:1 majority, the Committee found her guilty, and she was terminated on 23.02.2022.

The School Tribunal, Nagpur, quashed the termination on 21.03.2024 and called the inquiry “nothing but a farce of enquiry”. The High Court set this aside, holding that the inquiry was conducted in accordance with law.

READ ALSO  अनिश्चितकालीन निलंबन: सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने आप सांसद राघव चड्ढा से राज्यसभा अध्यक्ष से बिना शर्त माफी मांगने को कहा

Arguments

Advocate Sachin Patil, appearing for the teacher, argued that the Sanstha’s Executive Committee was dominated by the Masurkar family. He pointed out that Rajesh Masurkar acted as Secretary, issued the charge-sheet, conducted the inquiry as Chief Executive Officer, appeared as the principal witness and signed the termination order. He also submitted that Rajesh Masurkar was junior to her and had become Headmaster by superseding her seniority.

Senior Counsel Sudhanshu Choudhari, appearing for the Sanstha, argued that the teacher had accepted Prakash Masurkar as Convenor through a letter of 08.09.2021 and had waived her objection. He submitted that the MEPS Rules allow any Executive Committee member to be nominated, so the doctrine of necessity applied. He also argued that kinship alone does not show bias unless a specific instance of it is proved.

Reasonable Likelihood of Bias Is the Test

Tracing the law from A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India to Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India and the Pinochet case, the Court held that the test is not actual bias but a reasonable likelihood of bias from the view of a fair-minded person. It rejected the argument that the teacher had to prove a specific instance of bias as “not legally tenable”.

Recalling the anecdote of Justice Badruddin Tyabji, whose two sons appeared before him on opposite sides, the Court said kinship was once not treated as a disqualification. It held, “it is now well established that kinship does disqualify wherever it is close enough to give rise to a ‘reasonable likelihood of bias’.”

“Total Familial Capture”

The Court found that the inquiry was subjected to a “total familial capture”. The Convenor was the President’s brother-in-law, the Vice-President’s uncle and the husband of a Committee member. The Court also found that the complainant gave evidence before his own brother, who then held the teacher guilty.

The Court rejected the argument that Rajesh Masurkar was only a formal witness, noting that he was the sole witness on 11 of the 20 charges. It said his personal interest was “palpably evident” because he had become Headmaster by superseding her seniority.

READ ALSO  Interim Order Merges With Final Order Therefore No Benefit Can be Claimed in Case of Dismissal, Rules Supreme Court

The Bench held, “Permitting immediate family members to simultaneously function as the management, prosecutor, chief witness and adjudicator reduces the inquiry to a pre-arranged farce, rendering the consequential disciplinary action per se arbitrary, capricious and unconstitutional.”

It added, “An immediate blood relative of a person who initiates disciplinary action or who is directly interested in its outcome, is disqualified from acting as an adjudicator.”

Procedural Compliance Cannot Cure Bias

The Court held that holding hearings, examining witnesses or allowing cross-examination cannot cure bias. It said “bias affecting the root of the disciplinary mechanism is not a curable procedural irregularity but a foundational illegality which vitiates the entire proceedings.”

The Court held that the doctrine of necessity did not apply, since two unrelated members of the Executive Committee were available. It also rejected the argument that the bias of one member did not matter on a three-member committee, holding that in a group deliberation each member is bound to influence the others.

READ ALSO  1975 से पहले विभाजित भूमि पर ओएसआर शुल्क नहीं: सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने सीएमडीए की अपील खारिज की, ब्याज सहित रिफंड का आदेश बरकरार

No Waiver

The Court found that the teacher objected to Prakash Masurkar at every stage. It noted that the Inquiry Committee’s own report recorded her objection and rejected it on the ground that actual bias had not been established. It held that a waiver must be voluntary, informed and unequivocal, and that these requirements were not met.

The Court also noted that the High Court appeared to have mistaken the Convenor to be Rajesh Masurkar instead of Prakash Masurkar. It remarked that, given the number of Masurkars on the Executive Committee, some confusion was perhaps inevitable.

Outcome

The Court held that the inquiry proceedings were unsustainable in law. It allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court’s judgment and restored the School Tribunal’s order. It also directed the Education Officer to consider whether the teacher can be absorbed in any other 100% grant-in-aid school within its jurisdiction under Rule 26(2)(iii) of the MEPS Rules.

Case Title: Ku. Kiran D/o Purushottam Bhujade v. Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha & Ors.

Case No.: Civil Appeal No. ___ of 2026 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 16636 of 2025)

Bench: Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Manmohan

Date: November 17, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles