The Supreme Court has held that recovering tainted currency notes from a public servant, without proof that he demanded a bribe, cannot sustain a conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. It acquitted a former Tehsildar of Kotwali, Delhi, who was convicted in a 2003 trap case.
A Bench of Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar set aside the Delhi High Court’s judgment of 19.12.2014 and the trial court’s conviction of Har Parsad Gaur.
Background
The complainant, Puran Chand, had won a Labour Court award against his former employer, M/s. Pooja Printers, for unpaid wages. When the matter reached the Collectorate for recovery, it was marked to the appellant, who was then Tehsildar, Kotwali.
According to the complaint, the appellant first demanded ₹3,000 to speed up the recovery, and later another ₹1,000. On 06.01.2003, the Anti-Corruption Bureau laid a trap near the State Bank of India building at the Tis Hazari court complex. Two phenolphthalein-treated ₹500 notes were recovered from the inner pocket of the appellant’s coat, and his left hand wash and the pocket wash turned pink.
Both the complainant and the panch (shadow) witness died before they could give evidence at the trial. The Special Judge, Delhi, still convicted the appellant in 2008 by drawing the presumption under Section 20 of the PC Act. The High Court upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence from two years to one year of rigorous imprisonment.
Arguments
Senior Counsel Parthiv K Goswami, appearing for the appellant, argued that the basic facts of demand and voluntary acceptance were never proved because the complainant and panch witness had died. He submitted that the trap officer reached the spot only after the alleged transaction, so his account of what the panch witness told him was hearsay. Relying on the depositions of two clerks, he argued that the cheques had already been sent to the Deputy Labour Commissioner’s office by 01.01.2003, so there was no reason to demand a bribe on 06.01.2003.
Senior Counsel Dr. Nachiketa Joshi, appearing for the State, argued that the complaint contained detailed particulars of the demand, and that the recovery of the notes and the positive chemical tests were undisputed. He submitted that once marked money is recovered from a public servant, the presumption under Section 20 applies and the accused must rebut it.
Demand Is the Sine Qua Non
The Court relied on the Constitution Bench decision in Neeraj Dutta v. State (Government of NCT of Delhi). That decision holds that proof of demand and acceptance is essential, but that if the complainant dies, the demand can be proved through other witnesses or circumstantial evidence. The Court noted that the presumption under Section 20 can be drawn only once these basic facts are proved, and that it does not apply to Section 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii).
The Court also referred to P. Satyanarayana Murthy v. State of A.P., Aman Bhatia v. State and State of Uttar Pradesh v. A.K. Gaba. It distinguished P. Sarangapani and State of Karnataka v. Chandrasha, cited by the State, on the ground that demand and acceptance had been proved in those cases.
Trap Officer’s Version Is Hearsay
The Court found that the prosecution case rested entirely on the trap officer, Inspector S.S. Sandhu (PW-10), who had himself not seen or heard any demand or acceptance. It noted that in his examination-in-chief he said the panch witness told him the bribe was taken with the right hand, but in cross-examination he said the left hand.
The Bench held, “In the absence of the panch (shadow) witness testifying as to the correctness of the said statement, such hearsay statement of PW-10 would be inadmissible in evidence and cannot establish the fact in issue viz. the demand for and voluntary acceptance of illegal gratification by the appellant.”
What remained was the recovery and the chemical tests. On this, the Court said “mere recovery of tainted currency notes, absent proof of demand, cannot sustain a conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) of the PC Act.”
Official Records Contradict the Prosecution
The Court found that the official records went against the prosecution’s case on motive and demand. The order sheet and forwarding letter showed that the appellant’s office had sent both cheques on 28.12.2002, and they reached the Deputy Labour Commissioner’s office on 01.01.2003. The complainant collected the cheques from the Labour Department on 07.01.2003.
The Court held, “Therefore, no official work or proceeding in relation to the complainant was pending before the appellant on 06.01.2003.”
In his statement under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant had said the complainant met him to thank him for forwarding the cheques and tried to push the notes into his coat pocket while shaking hands. The Court said this explanation could not be discarded altogether. It held, “In view of the official records showing prior completion of work, the defence version was plausible and satisfied the test of pre-ponderance of probabilities.”
Outcome
The Court held that neither the demand nor the conscious acceptance of a bribe was proved, and that “In the absence of such proof, drawing of presumption under Section 20 of the PC Act was impermissible.”
Allowing the appeal, the Court set aside the judgments of the High Court and the Special Judge and acquitted the appellant of the charges under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the PC Act. As he was on bail, his bail bonds were discharged.
Case Title: Har Parsad Gaur v. State (NCT of Delhi)
Case No.: Criminal Appeal No. 571 of 2015
Bench: Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar
Date: November 17, 2026
