Daughter-In-Law’s Right Under DV Act Is A Right To Secure Residence, Not To Insist On In-Laws’ Property: Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court has held that a daughter-in-law’s right of residence under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDV Act) is a right to secure a residence. It does not give her an indefeasible right to live in a particular property belonging to her in-laws. Dr. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma upheld the order of the Divisional Commissioner directing a woman and her son to vacate a house in Pitampura at the instance of her elderly parents-in-law. However, the Court modified the order to add detailed safeguards for her alternate accommodation, with the in-laws paying rent of up to ₹35,000 a month.

Background

The petitioner, Namrata Yadav, married in 2008 and has lived since then at property No. HU-79, Pitampura, Delhi, with her son, who is now in Class XII. Her parents-in-law, aged about 70 and 64, live on the first floor. She lives in part of the ground floor. Her husband lives separately at Ashok Vihar.

Over nearly a decade, the parties have been in several proceedings against each other. These include divorce and custody petitions, a maintenance case, a PWDV Act case, criminal cases filed by each side, and civil suits. One of the civil suits was filed on behalf of the son, claiming that the house is Hindu Undivided Family property.

In June 2025, the parents-in-law applied to the District Magistrate under the Delhi Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009 for her eviction. They alleged ill-treatment, harassment and destruction of property. On 23.12.2025, after personally visiting the house, the District Magistrate refused eviction and directed both sides to continue living in their portions, subject to certain conditions. On appeal, the Divisional Commissioner reversed that order on 06.08.2026. He directed the petitioner and her son to vacate once the in-laws provided reasonable alternate accommodation.

Arguments

Senior Advocate Sandeep Sharma, appearing with Advocate Sanjay Rathi and others for the petitioner, argued that the Appellate Authority had in effect enforced a disputed title through summary proceedings. He submitted that the conveyance deed relied on by the mother-in-law derives title from a person who died 13 years before it was executed. He also argued that the in-laws’ applications for alternate accommodation had already been dismissed under the PWDV Act, which made the present proceedings forum shopping. He further submitted that the alleged incident outside the District Magistrate’s office was disputed and the videos doctored, and that the son, who was not a party, was being displaced.

READ ALSO  दीवानी मुकदमा, S.138 NI एक्ट के तहत आपराधिक कार्यवाही में बाधा नहीं: दिल्ली हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका जुर्माने के साथ खारिज की

Senior Advocate Mohit Mathur, appearing with Advocate Atul Guleria and others for the parents-in-law, argued that the house is one structure with a common porch and staircase, so conflict is a daily occurrence. He alleged that the petitioner had disconnected water and electricity and blocked the staircase, and he relied on FIR No. 394/2025 over the alleged incident outside the District Magistrate’s office. He said that the petitioner had not responded to the in-laws’ notices about alternate accommodation. He also submitted that the in-laws were willing to contribute ₹30,000 to ₹35,000 a month towards rent. Advocates Jagdish Chandra, Maanya Saxena and Aishwarya Sinha also appeared on the respondents’ side.

Living together “unworkable”

The Court said that the District Magistrate’s own findings, including that the petitioner had blocked the staircase and the direction not to cut off each other’s water and electricity, showed that the portions were not self-contained. They also showed that relations had deteriorated. The Court declined to rule on whether the incident outside the District Magistrate’s office had happened, leaving that to the criminal case. Even setting it aside, it found that the Appellate Authority’s conclusion that continued cohabitation was unworkable “is a plausible view on the material available on record, and cannot be termed as perverse”.

Title dispute and DV Act orders no bar

The Court held that an authority under the Senior Citizens Act does not decide title, and that even a modicum of right in the property is enough for a senior citizen to seek relief. It noted that the Appellate Authority had expressly said its order was not a ruling on title.

On forum shopping, the Court noted that the PWDV Act courts had rejected the in-laws’ applications mainly for lack of locus, and had pointed them to eviction proceedings. It held that “the invocation by respondent nos. 1 and 2 of the very remedy which the competent courts under the PWDV Act had themselves indicated cannot be characterised as forum shopping.”

Relying on S. Vanitha v. Deputy Commissioner and Satish Chander Ahuja v. Sneha Ahuja, the Court said that the two laws must be harmonised. It held that the right under the PWDV Act “does not, by itself, confer an indefeasible right to reside in a particular property belonging to the in-laws”, and that it may be secured through suitable alternate accommodation.

Directions lacked specificity

The Court found that the impugned order was “correct in principle”, but that its directions lacked the specificity needed to keep the right of residence from being rendered illusory. It did not say what standard of accommodation was required, for how long, or how rent would be paid. The Court also found the three-week timeline for relocating a woman who had lived there since 2008, along with a Class XII student, unjustified.

READ ALSO  दिल्ली हाईकोर्ट ने 1984 के सिख विरोधी दंगों के मामले में बरी किए जाने के खिलाफ अपील खारिज की

Modified directions

The Court modified the order and directed the following:

  • Finding a home: The petitioner is to identify, within four weeks, a home with two bedrooms, a drawing room and a kitchen, preferably near her son’s school.
  • Rent and costs: The in-laws will pay rent of up to ₹35,000 a month, plus the security deposit, brokerage and shifting costs. They must pay six months’ rent in advance.
  • Moving out: The petitioner and her son must vacate within two weeks after the advance is paid.
  • Duration: The rent obligation will continue until her right of residence is finally decided in the PWDV Act or matrimonial proceedings.
  • Default: If the in-laws default for two consecutive months, she may approach the Appellate Authority, which may also order restoration of possession.
  • Maintenance: This arrangement is in addition to the maintenance her husband has to pay.
  • Son’s suit: Everything remains subject to the son’s pending civil suit and appeal.
READ ALSO  Delhi HC Suspends Sentence of POCSO Convict, who is Sole Bread Winner of the Family

Case Title: Namrata Yadav v. Ramesh Kumar Yadav & Ors.
Case No.: W.P.(C) 12654/2026
Bench: Dr. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma
Date: November 19, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles