The Jharkhand High Court has held that a father who seeks his minor son’s custody as a natural guardian cannot have his petition under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 thrown out at the threshold just because no court has first appointed or declared him guardian under Section 7 of the Act.
A Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava set aside a Jamshedpur Family Court order that had dismissed the father’s custody suit as not maintainable. It sent the suit back to be decided on merits.
Background of the Custody Dispute
The parties married on 10.12.2017, and their son was born on 19.06.2020 in Chandigarh. The appellant, a doctor, says the respondent came back to Jamshedpur on 03.08.2022 and left the child with him in Chandigarh. Two days later, she lodged an FIR against him and his parents under Sections 498A, 506 and 34 of the IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act. The police later filed a final report in favour of his parents and a charge sheet against the appellant under Sections 498A and 506 IPC.
On a direction from the Investigating Officer, the appellant handed the child over to the respondent at Bistupur Police Station on 20.08.2022. Since then, the child has lived with his mother in Jamshedpur.
The father then filed a custody petition under Section 25 of the 1890 Act before the Principal Judge, Family Court, Jamshedpur. He also sought visitation rights under Section 12 of the Act. On 13.03.2024, the Family Court dismissed the suit at the admission stage. It said the petition should have been filed under Section 7 read with Section 17, because the father had never been appointed guardian by any court and the mother was also a natural guardian.
Arguments Before the High Court
Advocate Indrajit Sinha, appearing for the appellant along with Advocates Ajay Kumar Sah and Peeya Bhatia, argued that Section 7 deals with appointing or declaring a guardian and does not apply to a natural guardian. He argued that nothing in Sections 8 and 11 requires a natural guardian to obtain such a declaration before seeking custody under Section 25. He relied on Shazia Aman Khan v. State of Orissa, Athar Hussain v. Syed Siraj Ahmed and Raj Kumar Gupta v. Barbara Gupta.
Advocate Sumeet Gadodia, assisted by Advocate K.S. Nanda for the respondent, defended the Family Court order. He argued that Section 25 refers to “the custody of a guardian” and “return to the custody of his guardian”. Since the dispute was between two guardians, he said, a declaration under Section 7 was needed. He relied on Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of India and Ram Singh v. Lila Devi.
What the High Court Held on Sections 7 and 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act
The Bench said the two provisions apply in different situations. Section 7 deals with appointing or declaring a guardian. Section 25 deals with returning a ward who has left or been removed from a guardian’s custody. The Court observed:
“The mere fact that both provisions concern the welfare of a minor does not justify importing into Section 25 an inflexible condition that a person seeking relief thereunder must, in every case, first obtain a separate order of appointment or declaration under Section 7.”
On the scope of Section 25, the Court held that “The provision does not, either expressly or by necessary implication, mandate that such guardian must necessarily be a court-appointed guardian.”
The Court said recourse to Section 7 may become necessary where a person’s status as guardian is itself disputed. However, “where the applicant approaches the court in the capacity of a natural guardian recognized by law and seeks custody or ancillary reliefs concerning the minor, the petition cannot be rejected at the threshold merely on the ground that no prior declaration under Section 7 has been obtained.”
The Court also rejected the Family Court’s view that the mother’s status as a natural guardian barred the father’s claim. It observed that “The fact that the respondent-mother is also a natural guardian does not, by itself, extinguish the appellant’s status as a natural guardian or render his claim incapable of examination under Section 25.”
The Bench noted the proviso to Section 6(a) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, under which a child below five years should ordinarily be in the mother’s custody. It said this provision must be read with the rest of the law and the settled principle that the minor’s welfare is paramount.
Outcome
The High Court quashed the Family Court’s order dated 13.03.2024 and restored Original Suit No. 829 of 2023 for a fresh decision, with due opportunity to both parties. The Family Court was also directed to consider any pending application for visitation rights under Section 12 and may pass interim directions for visitation or interaction, keeping the child’s routine and emotional well-being in mind.
The Bench made clear that its ruling is limited to maintainability. It expressed no opinion on the allegations or on which parent should have custody. The appeal was allowed.
Case Title: Dr. Shantanu v. Vedika Kashyap
Case No.: F.A. No. 96 of 2024
Bench: Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava
Date: 29.10.2026
