The Calcutta High Court has acquitted three men sentenced to life imprisonment in a 2006 gang-rape case, holding that the prosecution failed to produce sufficient evidence to establish that the alleged victim had been sexually assaulted.
A Division Bench of Justice Rajasekhar Mantha and Justice Anuj Singh, in its November 13 judgement, overturned the conviction recorded by a trial court in 2018 in connection with the alleged gang-rape of a girl at Purbasthali in West Bengal’s Purba Bardhaman district.
The High Court found serious deficiencies in both the investigation and the prosecution’s evidence, observing that the material on record was insufficient to sustain the convictions.
Absence of Medical Evidence Raises Serious Doubts
The Bench emphasised the importance of medical examination in establishing allegations of rape under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
It noted that although the prosecution had recorded allegations of sexual assault, it failed to present medical evidence establishing that an assault had occurred.
The Court observed that the investigation had also fallen short of basic requirements, particularly because investigators neither seized the alleged victim’s clothing nor sent it for forensic examination.
The Bench concluded that the evidence presented by the prosecution, together with the deficiencies in the investigation, could not justify the trial court’s findings of guilt.
Victim’s Testimony Must Meet High Evidentiary Standards
Addressing the legal requirements for conviction in sexual offence cases, the High Court acknowledged that testimony from the victim alone could support a conviction under Section 376 IPC or Sections 4 and 6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012.
However, the Bench clarified that such testimony must be flawless, consistent with other established facts and of exceptional evidentiary quality. It also stressed the need for at least some supporting medical evidence.
The Court further held that the prosecution remained responsible for proving the allegations beyond the deficiencies in the defence’s case.
In particular, the failure of the appellants’ counsel to cross-examine prosecution witnesses, including the alleged victim, could not itself justify an inference of guilt.
Trial Court’s Age Determination Questioned
The High Court also identified an inconsistency in the trial court’s assessment of the girl’s age.
Despite referring to an ossification test report estimating her age between 15 and 17 years, the trial court had concluded that she was 13 years old.
The Division Bench questioned this finding and examined the absence of bodily injuries in the context of the prosecution’s allegations.
The judges reasoned that a 16-year-old girl would have resisted a sexual assault and that such resistance would have caused injuries. They noted that the girl, her mother and the examining doctor had all indicated that no injuries were present on her body.
Life Sentences Set Aside
After reviewing the evidence, the High Court held that the prosecution had failed to establish the allegations against the three appellants.
The Bench found the investigation inadequate and concluded that the trial court had erred in convicting the accused.
Accordingly, the High Court set aside the 2018 conviction and life sentences, acquitting all three appellants in the case.
