The Gauhati High Court has upheld a Foreigners Tribunal’s decision declaring a 45-year-old Assam woman a foreigner who entered India illegally after March 25, 1971, observing that a suspected illegal migrant cannot reasonably be expected to acknowledge unlawful entry or voluntarily provide an address in Bangladesh.
A Division Bench of Justices Kalyan Rai Surana and Pranjal Das, in its November 11 order, rejected the woman’s challenge to the tribunal’s 2016 ruling, finding no merit in her objections concerning the verification process and the grounds on which her nationality had been questioned.
The Court observed that just as a person accused of wrongdoing would ordinarily not admit guilt, an illegal foreigner or migrant could not be expected to acknowledge foreign nationality or disclose residential details in Bangladesh.
Court Examines Verification Procedure
Addressing objections to the inquiry conducted before the tribunal proceedings, the High Court examined the role of government officials assigned to verify suspected foreign nationals.
It noted that the Election Commission of India engages government employees for enumeration and verification work, although such officials do not receive investigative training comparable to that of police personnel.
The Bench held that an inquiry report could not be discarded merely because a suspected foreigner had failed to respond to verification questions or furnish supporting documents.
The Court consequently rejected the woman’s contention that the verification form had not been properly completed and that she had not been informed of the grounds for suspecting her nationality.
Woman Relied on Electoral Records to Establish Citizenship
The petitioner maintained that she was an Indian citizen by birth and had spent her childhood in an Assam village. She claimed that her father, an Indian citizen employed as a labourer, possessed no land records because the family lived in a hut on land belonging to others.
To support her citizenship claim, she referred to the inclusion of her parents’ names in the 1966 electoral roll of Belguri village.
She further submitted that her own name appeared in the 1997 voters’ list after she moved to her husband’s village following marriage. She also relied on an Electoral Photo Identity Card issued to her in 2014.
On these grounds, she had sought termination of the Foreigners Tribunal proceedings, maintaining that neither she nor her parents were foreign nationals.
However, the tribunal concluded that she had failed to establish Indian citizenship by birth through Indian parents and declared that she had entered Assam without authority.
Challenge to Tribunal Notice Rejected
Before the High Court, advocate P C Dey, representing the petitioner, questioned the validity of the notice issued in the proceedings.
He argued that the notice referred to two different periods of alleged entry into India. One concerned entry between January 1, 1966, and March 24, 1971, while the other related to entry after March 25, 1971.
Dey also submitted that the petitioner had not been provided with the principal grounds on which she was suspected of being a foreigner.
Central government counsel P Baruah represented the state.
After considering the objections, the High Court declined to interfere with the tribunal’s findings. It dismissed the woman’s petition and affirmed the declaration that she was a foreigner who had entered Assam illegally after March 25, 1971.
