The Bombay High Court has held that a transgender person who identifies as a woman can invoke Section 75 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), which penalises sexual harassment. The Court clarified that legal recognition of a person’s gender identity does not depend on obtaining a formal transgender identity certificate.
Justice Mehroz K Pathan of the Nagpur Bench delivered the ruling on November 3 while dismissing a criminal revision application filed by 24-year-old Army Agniveer Vishal Sunil Ingle. The Court upheld the Akot Sessions Court’s July 6 order refusing to discharge him from criminal proceedings initiated on a transgender woman’s complaint.
The High Court found that the allegations disclosed a prima facie case under Section 75 of the BNS and that questions concerning consent and an alleged promise of marriage required examination during trial.
Gender Identity Does Not Depend on Formal Certification
The High Court relied on the Supreme Court’s 2014 ruling in National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) v. Union of India, which recognised the right of individuals to determine their own gender identity.
Referring to the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, Justice Pathan observed that the statutory definition of a transgender person includes transgender women regardless of whether they have undergone sex reassignment surgery or hormonal treatment.
The Court rejected the contention that the complainant could not claim protection as a woman because she received her transgender identity certificate only in February 2026, after the alleged incidents.
It noted that the legal framework applicable in October 2025 already recognised the right to self-perceived gender identity. Consequently, the absence of a certificate at the relevant time did not prevent the complainant from seeking protection under the law.
Criminal Proceedings Against Army Agniveer
The prosecution arose from an FIR registered in Akola district on November 1, 2025, following allegations of sexual assault and harassment made by a transgender woman.
According to the prosecution, the complainant had been receiving hormonal treatment since 2015 and began wearing women’s clothing in 2021 as part of her gender transition.
She alleged that Ingle, who was serving in the Indian Army as an Agniveer, developed a relationship with her and assured her that he would marry her.
The complainant accused him of sexually assaulting her on October 28, 2025, on the pretext of marriage. She further alleged that on October 30, he called her to a bus stand, took her to a flat on his motorcycle and sexually assaulted her again.
Police registered offences under Sections 75 (sexual harassment), 296 (obscene acts) and 351(2) (criminal intimidation) of the BNS, along with Section 18(D) of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.
Defence Challenges Application of Section 75
Seeking discharge from the proceedings, Ingle’s counsel argued that Section 75 was intended to protect women and that the statutory definition of a woman referred to a female human being.
The defence maintained that the complainant’s transgender identity certificate, issued in February 2026, could not establish her status for incidents allegedly occurring in October 2025.
Counsel also asserted that the relationship between the parties was consensual and pointed out that the BNS contained no provision corresponding to the former Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code.
Additional Public Prosecutor Swati V Kolhe opposed the application, submitting that transgender persons identifying as women were entitled to statutory protection and that their gender identity could not be disputed.
Consent and Marriage Promise Must Be Examined at Trial
Rejecting the defence arguments at the discharge stage, the High Court held that allegations involving sexual assault and outraging the modesty of a woman could be maintained where the complainant was a transgender person identifying as a woman.
Justice Pathan observed that the defence claim of a consensual relationship could not be conclusively determined while considering an application for discharge.
The Court further held that whether the alleged promise of marriage was genuine and whether the relationship was consensual were issues requiring examination during trial.
Finding no justification to interfere with the Sessions Court’s decision, the High Court dismissed Ingle’s criminal revision application and upheld the rejection of his discharge plea.
