The Andhra Pradesh High Court has held that the custody of a minor child with the father, who is a natural guardian under law, cannot ordinarily be considered illegal. The Court dismissed a habeas corpus petition filed by a mother seeking the release of her 10-year-old son from his father’s custody, observing that allowing the child to go anywhere without appropriate care would be contrary to his welfare.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari and Justice Alapati Giridhar, in an order dated November 10, 2026, held that the petitioner had failed to establish how the father’s custody of the child was unlawful.
The Court also noted that the mother had not sought custody of the child for herself but had instead requested that he be set at liberty.
Background of the Case
The petitioner approached the High Court through a habeas corpus petition alleging that her approximately 10-year-old son was being illegally detained by his father.
The mother had earlier instituted divorce proceedings against her husband in FCOP No. 237 of 2026. An ex parte decree dissolving their marriage was passed on April 17, 2026.
Following the divorce, the child remained in the father’s custody.
In her writ petition, the mother sought directions to the authorities to trace, secure and produce the minor before the High Court. She also requested that the child be released from the alleged illegal detention and concealment by the fourth and fifth respondents.
The petition further sought a declaration that the respondents’ actions were illegal, arbitrary and violative of Article 21 of the Constitution.
Petitioner’s Arguments
Advocate Doddaka Harsha Vardhan, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the minor child was in the custody of the fourth respondent, who was the petitioner’s former husband.
He informed the Court that the marriage had already been dissolved through an ex parte divorce decree.
The counsel clarified that the mother was not seeking custody of the child through the habeas corpus proceedings. Instead, the petition had been filed to secure the child’s release from what she alleged was unlawful custody.
It was argued that the father’s continued custody of the minor was illegal and warranted the High Court’s intervention.
Court’s Analysis: Father’s Custody Cannot Ordinarily Be Considered Illegal
The High Court rejected the petitioner’s submissions, finding no sufficient basis to treat the father’s custody of the child as unlawful.
The Bench emphasised that the father is recognised as a natural guardian under law and that his custody of a minor cannot ordinarily be characterised as illegal.
The Court observed:
“Firstly, the custody of the minor child with the father ordinarily cannot be said to be an illegal custody. There is also no averment pointed out to us, as to how the custody of the minor child with the father is an illegal custody.”
The Bench further examined the relief sought in the habeas corpus petition and found that the mother had not requested that the child be placed in her custody.
Instead, she had asked the Court to set the child at liberty.
The judges held that such relief could not be granted in the circumstances, particularly considering the age and welfare of the minor.
The Court stated:
“We cannot set the minor aged about 10 years at liberty so as to go anywhere after taking him out of the custody of the father who under law is a natural guardian, and as that would also be contrary to the welfare of the child.”
The Bench thus identified two reasons for declining the petition: the absence of any demonstrated illegality in the father’s custody and the nature of the relief sought, which would not serve the child’s welfare.
Decision: Habeas Corpus Petition Dismissed
Finding no grounds to grant the requested relief, the Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed the habeas corpus petition.
However, the Bench granted the petitioner liberty, upon request, to pursue an appropriate remedy available under law through suitable proceedings.
The Court made no order as to costs and directed that any pending miscellaneous petitions would also stand closed.
Case Details
Case Title: Kancharla Durga Lavanya v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Case Number: Writ Petition No. 32567 of 2026
Bench: Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari and Justice Alapati Giridhar
Date of Judgement: November 10, 2026
