Supreme Court Orders Medical Examination of 70-Year-Old Double-Murder Convict After 45 Years of Litigation

The Supreme Court has ordered a fresh medical assessment of 70-year-old Simon Soren, the sole surviving convict in a 1981 double-murder case, as it continues to examine the prolonged judicial proceedings and his deteriorating health.

A Bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran directed the Chief Medical Officer of the District Government Hospital in Dumka, Jharkhand, to constitute a medical team and submit a report on Soren’s health condition.

Soren, whose life sentence was suspended by the Supreme Court on August 19, has been directed to appear before the hospital for examination. The Court also instructed the Superintendent of Police, Dumka, to facilitate the process through the Station House Officer of the police station having jurisdiction over Soren’s residence.

The Bench passed the directions on Thursday and scheduled the next hearing for March 3, 2027.

Plea For Policy On Release Of Elderly And Ailing Prisoners

During the hearing, Advocate Fauzia Shakil, representing Soren, referred to an earlier Supreme Court direction issued in July in proceedings initiated by the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA).

Under that direction, states and Union territories were required to formulate and notify a comprehensive policy within three months for the early or premature release of elderly prisoners and those suffering from terminal illnesses.

Shakil requested that the proceedings be deferred to allow the Jharkhand government to formulate and notify the policy.

The Bench instead directed an assessment of Soren’s present medical condition, having previously taken note of his serious health problems while granting him bail.

READ ALSO  30-Year-Old Delhi Judge Found Dead at South Delhi Residence; Police Suspect Suicide

Supreme Court Had Questioned Decades Of Judicial Delay

The medical examination order follows the Supreme Court’s August 19 decision suspending Soren’s sentence and directing his release on bail.

At that stage, the Court had described the nearly 50-year litigation as a failure of the judicial system, expressing concern over the extraordinary delay in concluding proceedings arising from the double murder.

The Court particularly questioned why the Jharkhand High Court had taken more than two decades to decide the appeal against Soren’s conviction.

Although six individuals were originally accused in the case, two died before charges were framed. Three others died while their appeals remained pending before the High Court, leaving Soren as the only surviving convict.

The Supreme Court noted that Soren, suffering from multiple ailments, had surrendered into custody following the High Court’s decision in 2024. He was subsequently admitted to hospital while remaining in custody.

The Bench also observed that Soren had spent only two years, four months and 12 days in custody, despite the gravity of the offence.

While acknowledging that the double murder was a serious crime, the Court considered the prolonged ordeal suffered by the accused over approximately 45 years and his medical condition sufficient grounds to suspend the sentence.

His release was made conditional upon his furnishing a personal surety and not committing any offence while on bail.

Court Sought Records To Examine Reasons For Delay

READ ALSO  Allegations Under Section 498A IPC and Dowry Act Cannot Be Ambiguous or Made in Thin Air: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court had also called for the original case records in both physical and digital formats, requesting the High Court and trial court to furnish them within four weeks.

The Court examined explanations concerning the unusually lengthy trial and appellate proceedings.

According to a report from the Registrar General of the High Court, the accused had remained absconding for six years, contributing to the delay. However, the Supreme Court found no explanation for the approximately 12 years taken to complete the trial after charges were framed in 1991.

The Court also referred to a report from the District and Sessions Judge indicating that the case had been transferred between courts five times over 11 years following the framing of charges.

The trial court had awarded life imprisonment in 2002. The Jharkhand High Court subsequently dismissed the appeal and upheld the conviction and sentence on October 28, 2024.

Double-Murder Case Dates Back To 1981

READ ALSO  P&H HC Rules that Registration Of Other Criminal Cases Against Accused Can’t Be The Sole Ground To Refuse Bail

The prosecution case arose from an incident on October 18, 1981, when Bibhuti Mandal, Banarsi Mandal and Kschir Sagar Mandal, accompanied by their nephews Jagdish Mandal and Satyanarayan Mandal, travelled to Bhurundia village in Dumka for paddy harvesting.

According to Jagdish and Satyanarayan, who later became informants, a group of Santhals assembled near a river after drumbeats were sounded. The group allegedly carried bows, arrows and axes and called for the killing of members of the Mandal family.

The family members attempted to escape but were pursued.

The prosecution alleged that Jethun Soren first shot Bibhuti Mandal with an arrow, followed by Simon Soren. Both were also accused of striking Banarsi Mandal with arrows.

After the two victims fell, Jagdish and Satyanarayan allegedly witnessed the accused attacking and killing them with sharp weapons.

The case ultimately resulted in convictions that were affirmed by the High Court in 2024, more than four decades after the incident.

With Soren currently on bail, the Supreme Court will now consider the medical team’s findings when the matter comes up for further hearing on March 3, 2027.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles