The Sikkim High Court has quashed an FIR and criminal proceedings against members of the Gorkha Seva Sena, holding that inviting the public to discuss the constitutional legality of the proposed Darjeeling-Sikkim unification does not constitute promoting enmity between communities under Section 196 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).
Justice Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, in an order dated November 7, ruled that differences of opinion over a proposed political or constitutional issue cannot, by themselves, attract criminal liability for promoting communal hostility.
The Court also examined allegations that the organisation had used the official logo of the Government of Sikkim without authorisation. While disapproving of the unauthorised use, it held that the act did not establish the offence alleged against the petitioners.
Public Consultation Invitation Led to FIR
The dispute originated from an invitation issued by the Darjeeling-based Gorkha Seva Sena for an event titled ’50th Sikkim State Day Celebration and Constitutional Consultation’, scheduled for June 15, 2025, at Town Hall in Kurseong.
The programme sought public participation in a discussion on the constitutional legality of Darjeeling-Sikkim unification.
On June 6, 2025, the Principal Secretary to the Chief Minister lodged an FIR alleging that the invitation cards carried the official logo and theme of the Government of Sikkim without its permission or approval.
According to the complaint, the use of government symbols in connection with such a sensitive subject could create the false impression that the Sikkim government supported or was associated with the organisation.
The FIR further alleged that the event could generate hostility between residents of Sikkim and Darjeeling, disturb public order and weaken public confidence in the government.
Following the filing of a chargesheet, the accused approached the High Court seeking to have the FIR and subsequent criminal proceedings quashed.
Petitioners Invoke Constitutional Freedom of Expression
Senior Advocate N Rai and Advocate Tara Devi Chettri, representing the petitioners, argued that the proposed consultation was protected by the constitutional guarantee of freedom of thought and expression.
They submitted that disagreement with an individual’s or organisation’s views must be addressed through opposing arguments rather than criminal prosecution. The petitioners maintained that even widely unpopular opinions deserve constitutional protection.
Additional Public Prosecutor Yadev Sharma, appearing for the state, defended the prosecution on the ground that displaying the government’s official logo in an invitation concerning an extremely sensitive and potentially inflammatory subject could have dangerous consequences.
Court Distinguishes Public Debate From Promotion of Enmity
After examining the invitation and the allegations in the FIR, the High Court found that the petitioners had called for public participation in a consultation concerning the constitutional legality of the proposed unification.
The Court observed that opposing views on such an issue, including strong disagreement between different groups, could not automatically be treated as an offence under Section 196 of the BNS.
It emphasised that discussions about what one group considers a desirable course of action should not provoke reactions of such intensity that the criminal provision against promoting enmity becomes applicable.
The Court also referred to the Preamble of the Constitution, which guarantees citizens liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship.
Addressing the allegation concerning the Sikkim government’s logo, the High Court observed that the petitioners ought not to have used the official emblem without permission. However, it found that the unauthorised use did not amount to promoting enmity between different communities.
FIR and Criminal Proceedings Quashed
The High Court consequently quashed the FIR and the criminal proceedings arising from it, granting relief to the Gorkha Seva Sena members.
At the same time, the Court cautioned the petitioners against engaging in mischievous activities harmful to society through the misuse of property belonging to others.
