Foetal Viability Irrelevant When Minor Is Determined To End Pregnancy; Bombay High Court Allows 28-Week Termination

The Bombay High Court has allowed a 17-year-old survivor of sexual assault to terminate her 28-week pregnancy, even though a Medical Board found no lethal congenital anomaly in the foetus. The Court held that the State and the hospital must take full responsibility for the child if it is born alive.

A Bench of Justice Advait M. Sethna and Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale, sitting as a Vacation Court, relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in A (Mother of X) v. State of Maharashtra. That ruling held that a pregnant woman’s reproductive autonomy and bodily integrity must be given sufficient emphasis over the rights of the unborn foetus.

Background

The petitioner, aged 17 years and 7 months, approached the High Court along with her father. She had lodged an FIR under Sections 4, 4(1), 6 and 10 of the POCSO Act, read with Section 64(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. She learnt of the pregnancy only in November 2026, when a sonography showed she was about seven months pregnant.

As the statutory limit under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act had passed, the Court directed that a Medical Board be constituted at Sir J.J. Group of Hospitals, Mumbai. The Board’s report, opened in court in a sealed cover, put the pregnancy at 28 weeks with no lethal congenital anomaly. The Board said that permitting termination was beyond its purview. However, it added that termination could be performed if the Court so directed, given the possibility of grave and irreparable harm to the survivor’s psychological health. It also cautioned that the foetus may be born alive and would need neonatal intensive care, with significant comorbidity and mortality.

Submissions

Legal Aid Counsel Kanchan Pawar, appearing for the petitioners, submitted that the minor was neither mentally nor physically ready to bear the child. She said the pregnancy was without the minor’s consent, and continuing it would cause grave mental anguish and trauma. Invoking the right to live with dignity and reproductive freedom under Article 21, she sought permission for termination under Section 3(2)(b) read with Section 5 of the MTP Act.

READ ALSO  जज को धमकाने पर दो वकील अवमानना के दोषी, बॉम्बे हाईकोर्ट ने बार काउंसिल को भेजा मामला

AGP M. P. Thakur, appearing for the State, relied on the Medical Board’s report and left it to the Court to pass an appropriate order.

Interaction In Chambers

The judges met the petitioner and her parents in chambers. They explained the Board’s opinion, the option of giving the child in adoption, and the possibility of a live birth. The parents said they could not look after a newborn because of their precarious financial condition. The petitioner conveyed that she did “not desire to continue with the pregnancy under any circumstances whatsoever.”

Court’s Findings

The Bench noted that Rule 3-B of the MTP Rules, 2003 allows minors and survivors of sexual assault to terminate a pregnancy up to 24 weeks, while this pregnancy was at about 28 weeks. Turning to A (Mother of X), decided by the Supreme Court on 6 February 2026, the Bench recorded that the Supreme Court had allowed termination of a 30-week pregnancy and set aside a High Court decision that had refused termination on grounds of foetal viability and adoption.

The Bench held that the precedent “would clearly and squarely apply to the given factual situation and we are bound to follow the same with due deference.” It found that the petitioner had “completely detached herself from the considerations such as whether the child would be born healthy or is viable, which are not relevant to her.”

Safeguards For Child Born Alive

The Bench relied on a Co-ordinate Bench ruling in XYZ v. Union of India (2019). That ruling held that the doctor and hospital must ensure the best medical treatment for a child born alive, and that the State must take full responsibility if the parents cannot. Agreeing with it, the Bench declared that the child, if born alive, must not be “neglected or left to perish or completely at the hands of fate which is as uncertain as is unknown.”

The Court referred to a case before its Kolhapur Circuit Bench, where a baby born alive was given no treatment for about 11 hours and died. In that case, the State was directed to decide on lodging an FIR against the doctors. The Bench said, “We solemnly hope that this is only a single isolated case and an exception that should never recur, in times to come.”

Outcome

The Court allowed the petition and permitted the termination at J.J. Group of Hospitals, following the protocol under Section 4 of the MTP Act. The hospital must provide post-delivery care, including neonatal care for the baby if required. If the petitioner wishes to give the child in adoption, the State and its agencies will take complete responsibility, including foster care or adoption through due legal process. The Court clarified that these observations do not bind the petitioners.

The Bench also appreciated both counsel, noting that the case required the Court to “strike a delicate balance between the facts, the law and human sentiments, sensibilities and feelings of parties.”

Case Title: XYZ and Another v. The State of Maharashtra and Others

Case No.: Writ Petition No. 15243 of 2026

READ ALSO  No Litigant Can Disadvantage the Opponent by Squirreling Some Information into the Court Record in Sealed Cover: Bombay HC

Bench: Justice Advait M. Sethna and Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale

Date: 09.11.2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles