The Supreme Court has held that recovering a dead person’s ornaments from an accused cannot, by itself, prove murder unless there is cogent evidence that the theft and the killing were part of the same transaction. It acquitted a Karnataka man who was serving a life sentence for a 2013 murder.
A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi set aside the conviction of Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja under Section 302 IPC, which the Karnataka High Court had confirmed on 09.07.2024.
Background
On 05.09.2013, the body of a woman was found stuffed inside an iron drum near a lime kiln at Harapanahalli in Davanagere district. Her relatives identified her two days later. She had left a family function at Mitlakatte village on 04.09.2013 wearing gold and silver ornaments, which were missing when her body was found.
The prosecution alleged that the appellant was in a relationship with the woman, suspected her of being involved with another man, strangled her with a plastic strap and took her ornaments. He was arrested on 12.09.2013, and the police said ornaments were recovered from his house on the basis of his disclosure statement.
The Sessions Court, Davanagere, rejected the “last seen together” evidence but convicted him in 2017 on the strength of the recovery, sentencing him to life imprisonment. It acquitted him under Section 201 IPC. The High Court upheld the conviction and also accepted the “last seen” evidence.
Arguments
Senior Advocate A. Sirajudeen, appearing for the appellant, argued that the case rested entirely on circumstantial evidence and that the alleged motive was never proved. He submitted that the High Court relied on the “last seen” witnesses without addressing the trial court’s finding that their statements were recorded after an unexplained delay of 58 days. Relying on Sanwat Khan v. State of Rajasthan and Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi), he argued that possession of the deceased’s articles only raises a presumption of theft, not murder. He also questioned the credibility of the recovery witnesses.
Additional Advocate General Avishkar Singhvi, appearing for the State of Karnataka, argued that family members had testified about the relationship and that the “last seen” witnesses had natural occasions to see the two together. He submitted that the recovery of ornaments within a week, without any explanation from the accused, was clinching evidence. Relying on Shri Bhagwan v. State of Rajasthan and State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, he argued that such recovery justifies an inference of guilt for both theft and murder when they form a single transaction.
Motive Not Proved
Examining each link in the chain, the Court held that “both the Trial Court and the High Court committed an error by treating the general knowledge of an illicit relationship as proof of the motive to commit murder.”
It noted that the nephew and the husband admitted in cross-examination that they had no personal knowledge of the relationship, and that no witness said the appellant suspected the woman or had quarrelled with her. The Court held that “the motive alleged by the prosecution is a matter of conjecture and surmise, which cannot be accepted as an established circumstance against the appellant.”
“Last Seen” Evidence Rightly Rejected
The Court noted that the statements of the two “last seen” witnesses were recorded under Section 161 CrPC only on 01.11.2013. It found that the High Court “relied upon their testimonies without addressing the 58-day delay or providing any reasoning for reversing the said finding of the Trial Court.” It held that the trial court had rightly rejected this evidence.
The Court also found inconsistencies in the account of how the body was discovered. The person who phoned the complainant was never traced, and neither the inquest report nor the post-mortem report showed any trace of lime on the body or clothing. It noted that the State had not appealed the acquittal under Section 201 IPC, which had attained finality.
Recovery Doubtful
The Court found the recovery itself doubtful. One of the three panch witnesses was never examined, and the other two did not speak to the disclosure statement, so the requirements of Section 27 of the Evidence Act were not met. One panch witness admitted that the police officer dictated the seizure mahazar. The appraiser admitted that he was a regular police witness, had signed only one document that day and had not carried a weighing machine.
The Court held that the prosecution failed to prove that the woman was wearing the recovered ornaments when she was last seen with the appellant. It also noted that one “last seen” witness had admitted that the police told him, the day after the incident, that the ornaments had already been found at the appellant’s house. That contradicted the prosecution’s case that they were recovered eight days later. The Court added that no charge of theft or robbery was ever framed.
Following Sanwat Khan and Raj Kumar, the Court held, “in the absence of cogent evidence showing that the robbery/theft and murder formed part of the same transaction, we are of the view that such recovery, by itself, cannot be stretched to infer guilt of the appellant for murder under Section 302 IPC.”
Outcome
Recalling Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra on the gap between “may be” and “must be” guilty, the Court held that the chain of circumstances was not complete. It said, “The findings of guilt recorded by the Trial Court and confirmed by the High Court are based on conjectures and surmises.”
Allowing the appeal, the Court set aside the conviction and the life sentence and acquitted the appellant under Section 302 IPC. It kept his acquittal under Section 201 IPC in place, and directed that he be released forthwith unless he is required in any other case.
Case Title: Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja v. State by Harapanahalli Police
Case No.: Criminal Appeal No. 5402 of 2026
Bench: Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi
Date: November 18, 2026
