Calcutta High Court Upholds Eviction Notice Against Schoolteacher, Orders Payment of Rs 2.82 Lakh Rent Arrears

The Calcutta High Court has upheld an eviction notice issued to a government-aided schoolteacher occupying residential accommodation at the Kolaghat Thermal Power Station (KTPS), holding that she was liable to pay rent under the applicable guidelines. The court, however, allowed her to clear outstanding dues of Rs 2.82 lakh in eight equal monthly instalments.

In an order dated November 16, Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee found no legal defect in the eviction notice issued on April 22, 2025. While recognising the authority’s right to recover the dues, the court questioned its decision to raise the demand nearly a decade after introducing the relevant guidelines in 2016.

The court held that the teacher could not avoid paying the prescribed charges after having occupied and benefited from the accommodation. It also found that the eviction notice did not infringe any of her legally protected rights.

Court Allows Eight Instalments to Clear Dues

The High Court directed the teacher to pay the outstanding Rs 2.82 lakh in eight equal monthly instalments, beginning in December 2026. Each instalment must be deposited on or before the 10th of the respective month.

READ ALSO  Meat Shop Closures During Kanwar Yatra Challenged in Allahabad High Court for Violating Fundamental Rights

The court further clarified that if the teacher failed to comply with the payment schedule, the KTPS authority would be entitled to initiate consequential action in accordance with law.

Although the court upheld the demand, it sought to know why the authority had not enforced the revised payment conditions soon after issuing its November 10, 2016 circular.

Dispute Over Quarter Allotted in 2008

The petitioner served as an assistant teacher at Kolaghat Thermal Power Station Primary School, a government-aided institution. She applied for residential accommodation within the KTPS premises on September 18, 2008.

The authority allotted her a quarter on December 5, 2008, initially fixing the monthly rent at Rs 816, subject to revision. In January 2016, the rent was increased to Rs 979 per month.

KTPS subsequently introduced guidelines on November 10, 2016, regulating the allotment of departmental residential quarters to outsiders and outside agencies.

Under these guidelines, school employees occupying KTPS accommodation without receiving departmental quarters from their parent departments were required to pay an amount equivalent to their housing rent allowance (HRA) as rent directly to the West Bengal Power Development Corporation Limited (WBPDCL).

The authority first demanded arrears of Rs 53,485 from the teacher in August 2020, directing her to deposit the amount within 30 days. She made the payment on October 15, 2020.

READ ALSO  Husband being in Income Tax Department Obtained ITR of Wife Illegally- Disciplinary Inquiry Instituted Against Husband

Following another demand, she deposited an additional Rs 16,643 on December 22, 2021.

However, on April 22, 2025, KTPS issued an eviction notice citing unpaid HRA-linked rent arrears of Rs 2.82 lakh for the period between November 2016 and December 2024. The notice informed her that the management had decided to discontinue the accommodation facility after considering the matter.

The teacher challenged the notice before the High Court.

Arguments Before the High Court

Advocate Salil Kumar Maiti, representing the teacher, contended that the eviction decision was illegal because it was inconsistent with the November 10, 2016 circular governing residential allotments.

Senior advocate Ranjay De, appearing for the KTPS authority, defended the notice as being consistent with the circular. He submitted that the teacher had defaulted on her payment obligations and that the authority had committed neither a procedural irregularity nor any illegality in initiating eviction proceedings.

READ ALSO  Allahabad HC Refuses Bail to Govt Servant Accused of Waging War against India by Converting People to Islam

Guidelines Binding on Teacher, Holds Court

After examining the allotment conditions and the 2016 guidelines, the High Court concluded that the petitioner fell within the category of outsiders occupying accommodation provided by KTPS.

The court found that the guidelines specifically required eligible school employees residing in such quarters to pay rent equivalent to their HRA to WBPDCL when their parent departments had not provided them with departmental accommodation.

Since the petitioner had occupied the quarter during the relevant period, the court held that she remained bound by the prescribed payment conditions.

At the same time, Justice Mukherjee questioned the authority’s prolonged delay in seeking recovery under the revised guidelines, particularly when the circular had been in operation since November 2016.

Nevertheless, finding no infirmity in the eviction notice, the High Court declined to interfere with it and permitted the teacher to discharge her outstanding liability through the instalment arrangement.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles