Lump-Sum Hike in Accident Compensation Without Head-Wise Basis Is Guesswork: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that when a High Court raises motor accident compensation by one combined amount without explaining how it got there, that is guesswork rather than an application of the law. It said appellate courts must check each head of compensation the Tribunal awarded. The Court raised the compensation for a milk vendor who suffered 50% permanent disability to his right leg to ₹11,75,106.

A Bench of Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar allowed the injured claimant’s appeal and modified the judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High Court at Gwalior.

Background

On 24.04.2013, the appellant, Mohammad Sabir, was riding his motorcycle with his wife near Kotwali Datia area when a truck hit them. Both were injured. He filed a claim petition before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gwalior, under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

He produced a Disability Certificate showing 50% permanent disability to his right leg. He said he earned ₹15,000 a month collecting and selling milk, and he was between 27 and 30 years old. The Tribunal found the truck driver rash and negligent. It took ₹4,000 a month as his notional income and awarded ₹2,33,130 with 7% interest a year.

His appeal before the High Court was dismissed on 29.04.2015 because defects in it were not removed in time. It was restored on 26.04.2024, on the condition that he would get no interest on any enhanced amount for the period it stayed dismissed. The High Court then raised the compensation by ₹2,00,000.

READ ALSO  Section 11 Petition Not Maintainable for Foreign-Seated Arbitration; 'Mother Agreement' with Benin Seat Prevails Over Ancillary Contracts: SC

Arguments

Senior Advocate N.K. Mody, appearing for the appellant, argued that the ₹4,000 monthly income was below the minimum wages of an unskilled labourer. He said the courts should have taken a pragmatic approach instead of insisting on strict proof of income. He added that the Disability Certificate had been ignored and that higher amounts should have been given for future prospects, medical expenses, attendant charges and pain and suffering.

The driver and the owner of the truck did not contest the appeal. Advocate Sanathana Bhaarath, appearing for the insurer, argued that ₹4,000 was rightly taken as notional income because there was no evidence of earnings. He also said the doctor had opined that the disability would reduce with treatment, so the appellant’s earning capacity was not seriously affected.

Supreme Court’s findings

The Court noted that the High Court raised the award by ₹2,00,000 “without indicating the manner in which it arrived at the said figure.”

It observed that “the High Court ought to have adverted to each head under which compensation was awarded by the Tribunal and then determined whether such grant was just or not.”

The Bench added: “A composite increase in the amount of compensation without indicating the basis for the same could be termed as an exercise of guesswork rather than applying the law laid down in this regard.” It relied on Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, which sets out the heads of compensation in personal injury cases.

Because there was no evidence of the appellant’s income, the Court took the minimum wage of an unskilled worker at the time of the accident, ₹5,270 a month, as his notional income. It applied a multiplier of 17 for his age, taken as 30 years.

On disability, the Court considered that his work involved travelling from place to place to collect and sell milk. It held that “the appellant’s mobility would definitely be affected” and assessed his functional disability at 50%, referring to Indra Bai v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Relying on National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi, it added 40% for future prospects.

The Court awarded:

  • ₹7,52,556 as net income (including future prospects)
  • ₹31,620 for six months’ loss of earnings
  • ₹15,930 for medical expenses, which it kept unchanged
  • ₹50,000 for special diet and transportation
  • ₹1,00,000 for pain and suffering
  • ₹25,000 for attendant charges
READ ALSO  SC agrees to hear on July 17 plea of NCP leader Nawab Malik in ED case

Together with the High Court’s lump-sum enhancement of ₹2,00,000, the total came to ₹11,75,106.

Outcome

The Court held that the appellant is entitled to ₹11,75,106 with 7% interest a year from 28.06.2013, the date of the claim petition, until realisation. The High Court’s condition still applies: no interest is payable on the enhanced amount for 29.04.2015 to 26.04.2024.

The High Court’s judgment dated 01.09.2025 in Miscellaneous Appeal No.548 of 2014 was modified on these terms, and the appeal was allowed with no order as to costs.

Case Title: Mohammad Sabir v. Ramesh Prasad and Others

READ ALSO  मंगलवार 31 जनवरी 2023 को सुप्रीम कोर्ट में महत्वपूर्ण मामलों की सुनवाई

Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 13804 of 2026

Bench: Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar

Date: 20.11.2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles