Centre Has No Objection to Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai Mediating Reliance KG Basin Gas Dispute, Supreme Court Told

The Centre informed the Supreme Court on Thursday that it has no objection to former Supreme Court judge Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai serving as the sole mediator in the Krishna-Godavari (KG) basin gas migration dispute involving Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL), BP Exploration (Alpha) Ltd and Niko (NECO) Ltd.

Attorney General R Venkataramani conveyed the government’s position to a bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana after concerns emerged over whether the Centre supported Justice Desai’s role in the mediation process.

The Attorney General explained that Justice Desai had apprehensions about a possible government objection to her appointment. He clarified that the Centre had already communicated its consent to her.

Chief Justice Surya Kant pointed out that the appointment had been made with the agreement of both sides.

Selection of Domain Experts Raises Concerns

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing a private party, raised the question of appointing two technical experts to assist Justice Desai during mediation.

Sibal informed the bench that the government had suggested a former petroleum secretary as one of the experts. While expressing no objection to the individual in principle, he maintained that the former official should not participate if he had previously dealt with the dispute in an official capacity.

READ ALSO  SC comes to rescue of 284 displaced students of strife-torn Manipur

Referring to assurances given by the Attorney General, Sibal said the parties wanted to resolve the issue amicably.

The Supreme Court had appointed Justice Desai as mediator on October 30 after observing that the parties had been unable to arrive at a workable settlement themselves. The bench also requested that two domain experts, suggested by the parties, assist her in resolving the dispute.

The Attorney General had assured the court of the government’s full cooperation in the mediation process.

Appeals Against Delhi High Court Verdict

The mediation proceedings arise from appeals filed by Reliance Industries and its foreign partners, BP Exploration (Alpha) Ltd and Niko (NECO) Ltd, challenging a Delhi High Court judgement that overturned an arbitral award in their favour.

On February 14, 2025, a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court allowed the Centre’s appeal against a May 9, 2023, single-judge decision that had upheld the arbitration award.

The dispute concerns allegations that the Reliance-led consortium extracted natural gas that had migrated from adjoining blocks operated by Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC) into RIL’s KG-D6 block in the Bay of Bengal.

In July 2018, an international arbitral tribunal rejected the government’s compensation claim of approximately $1.55 billion. The three-member tribunal, by a 2:1 majority, also awarded $8.3 million in compensation to the consortium.

READ ALSO  Cauvery water dispute: SC refuses to interfere with orders directing Karnataka to release 5,000 cusecs of water to Tamil Nadu

The Delhi High Court’s single judge subsequently upheld the award, finding insufficient grounds to conclude that the arbitral tribunal’s findings were unreasonable. However, the Division Bench later reversed that decision.

During proceedings on May 20, the Supreme Court declined Reliance’s request to defer the hearing while the three companies pursued mediation or conciliation with the Centre.

How the $1.55 Billion Dispute Began

The controversy originated from ONGC’s allegation that gas had migrated from its KG-DWN-98/2 and Godavari PML blocks into the neighbouring KG-D6 block operated by Reliance.

Following proceedings initiated by ONGC, the government constituted a committee headed by retired Supreme Court judge Justice A P Shah pursuant to directions of the Delhi High Court.

In its report dated August 28, 2016, the committee concluded that the KG-D6 contractor had benefited from the production of migrated gas, resulting in unjust enrichment. Justice Shah recommended that compensation be paid to the government, which owns unproduced natural resources.

READ ALSO  Superficial Changes Facilitating Use Do Not Amount to ‘Manufacture’; Excise Duty Cannot Be Levied Absent Emergence of a Distinct Product: Supreme Court

Acting on the findings, the petroleum ministry issued a demand on November 4, 2016, concerning approximately 338.332 million British thermal units of gas allegedly produced during the seven years ending March 31, 2016.

The initial demand was approximately $1.47 billion. After adjusting the $71.71 million royalty already paid and adding interest of $149.86 million, calculated at LIBOR plus 2 per cent, the total claim stood at approximately $1.55 billion.

Reliance challenged the demand, contending that it rested on an incorrect interpretation of the Production Sharing Contract (PSC) and had no precedent in the petroleum industry. The company issued an arbitration notice on November 11, 2016.

RIL operates the KG-D6 block with a 60 per cent participating interest, while BP holds 30 per cent and Niko Resources holds the remaining 10 per cent.

The dispute, which has moved through arbitration and successive proceedings before the Delhi High Court and Supreme Court, is now the subject of a court-facilitated mediation process led by Justice Desai.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles