Section 34 Court Cannot Substitute Its Own Reading of Contract for Arbitrator’s Plausible View: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that a court hearing a challenge to an arbitral award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 cannot replace the arbitrator’s possible and plausible reading of a contract with its own. On that basis, it dismissed Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd.’s (RVUNL) petition against arbitral awards in favour of Parsa Kente Collieries Limited (PKCL).

A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh upheld the Rajasthan High Court’s judgment of 21.05.2026, which had restored the award of 15.01.2021 and the additional award of 05.07.2021.

Article 136 Is the Exception in Arbitration

The Court first set out how far it can go under Article 136 in arbitration matters. It said the legal journey of an award ordinarily ends at the Section 37 stage, and that “introducing Article 136 of the Constitution into this legal path would be an exception rather than the norm”.

Relying on DMRC Ltd. v. Delhi Airport Metro Express (P) Ltd., the Bench said its role was limited to testing whether the Section 37 court exceeded its jurisdiction by failing to apply the correct tests.

The Coal Block Dispute

RVUNL, a Government of Rajasthan undertaking, and PKCL, a joint venture company set up to develop the Parsa East and Kanta Basan (PEKB) coal block, signed a Coal Mining and Delivery Agreement (CMDA) on 16.07.2008.

In 2014, the Supreme Court cancelled the allocation of 204 coal blocks, including PEKB, in Manohar Lal Sharma v. Principal Secretary. The block was re-allotted to RVUNL in 2015 under the Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015. The parties then signed a Supplementary Agreement on 29.07.2016 to continue the CMDA.

PKCL raised nine claims before Sole Arbitrator Justice Sudhir Kumar Katriar (Retd.). These included:

  • ₹71.78 crore for coal rakes that RVUNL rejected on quality grounds
  • ₹83.48 crore in stamp duty and other charges for registering the fresh mining lease
  • ₹67.27 crore as short-paid interest on overdue payments
  • claims for legal fees, bank guarantee charges, resettlement of 267 additional project-affected families, a vocational training centre and land acquisition costs
READ ALSO  स्कूलों में रैगिंग और बुलिंग के खिलाफ केंद्रीय कानून की मांग: सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने नई याचिका पर विचार करने से किया इनकार

The Arbitrator allowed most of the claims and awarded simple interest at 11.95% per annum and costs of ₹2.19 crore. The additional award granted ₹66.70 crore for land acquisition in four villages.

The Commercial Court No. 1, Jaipur Metropolitan-II, upheld the findings on Claims 1, 3, 5 and 9 but set aside those on Claims 2, 4, 6, 7 and 8. Holding that it had no power to modify the award, it set aside both awards in full on 20.05.2023. The High Court reversed that order under Section 37.

Arguments Before the Supreme Court

RVUNL argued that the High Court restored the awards through a single, omnibus finding without testing each claim. It sought a claim-wise severability exercise under Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd., or a remand to the Commercial Court for that purpose. On Claim 1, it argued that Clauses 4.3.3 and 5.4.1 of the CMDA barred any payment for coal rejected on quality parameters.

PKCL argued that RVUNL had consumed the coal and had not proved any loss, and that the claims arose from separate notices and were severable.

READ ALSO  Rajasthan High Court Quashes Conviction in Cheque Bounce Case Post-Compromise, Imposes 7.5% Cost

Court Examines Each Claim

The Bench examined all nine claims one by one. On the stamp duty claim, the Commercial Court had held that the Arbitrator read “adversely” in the force majeure clause without “directly”. The Supreme Court held, “Whether that is the only possible construction is not the question, but whether it is a construction that no fair-minded person could take.” It found that the Commercial Court exceeded its jurisdiction by substituting its own construction of Clause 7.1.

On Claim 4 (legal fees), the Court held that the Commercial Court acted “as if it was sitting on appeal on facts and law”.

On Claim 8, the Commercial Court had set aside the additional award on limitation. The Bench noted that limitation had never been pleaded before the Arbitrator. It held that “a plea not raised before the Tribunal ought not to have been considered by the Commercial Court in the challenge under Section 34 of the Act.”

On Claims 6 and 7, the Court held that the Arbitrator’s findings were possible views and that the Commercial Court went beyond the scope of Section 34. It found no reason to interfere with the concurrent findings on Claims 1, 3, 5 and 9.

READ ALSO  Mere Absence of Direct Evidence Cannot Dislodge a Complete Chain of Circumstantial Evidence: Supreme Court

The Court did not decide whether RVUNL could challenge Claims 1, 3, 5 and 9 without filing a cross-objection, because RVUNL had argued those claims fully on merits before it. Since no part of the awards was found invalid, the Court held that severability and remand did not arise.

Not a Review on Merits

The Bench clarified that its claim-wise examination was not a review on merits. It observed, “We have not asked whether we would have reached the same conclusion on the same material.”

It added, “Where the interpretation adopted is a possible and plausible one, the court cannot substitute its own interpretation, however persuasive the alternative reading may be.”

Finding no ground to interfere within the limited scope of Article 136, the Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition and made no order as to costs.

Case Title: Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Limited

Case No.: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 32968 of 2026

Bench: Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh

Date: November 16, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles