The Bombay High Court has held that public toilets constructed near protected monuments cannot be treated as prohibited construction under heritage conservation laws, observing that providing basic sanitation facilities is essential to protecting historical sites and accommodating visitors.
A Division Bench of Justices Kishore C Sant and Jitendra Jain at the Aurangabad Bench quashed stop-work notices issued by the Maharashtra Archaeological Department in 2018 against the construction of a public toilet block near Dargah Hazrat Sayed Shah Raju Khattal Husaini in Khuldabad, near Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar.
The Court held that providing toilets within 100 metres of a protected monument, but away from its boundary, would support heritage preservation rather than undermine it, particularly where thousands of devotees visit the site.
Basic Sanitation Necessary For Heritage Protection
The Bench considered the difficulties faced by visitors to the dargah, especially during the annual Urs festival, when thousands of devotees, including those from other states, gather at the shrine.
It accepted the petitioner’s submission that the absence of adequate sanitation facilities caused serious inconvenience to devotees and that preventing the proposed facility would adversely affect the monument’s surroundings.
The Court observed that denying visitors access to enclosed toilets could result in greater harm to the protected site than permitting the construction of public conveniences nearby.
It further emphasised that heritage conservation could not be separated from the provision of essential facilities for people visiting historical and religious places.
Dispute Over Construction Within 100 Metres
The proceedings arose from a petition filed by the mutawalli (custodian) of Dargah Hazrat Sayed Shah Raju Khattal Husaini challenging notices issued by the state Archaeological Department in October and November 2018.
The Khuldabad Municipal Council had undertaken the construction of a public toilet block using funds provided by the Maharashtra government under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan and recommendations of the 14th Finance Commission.
The project was intended to discourage open defecation and provide sanitation facilities to visitors. Although the proposed site was outside the dargah’s boundary, it fell within a 100-metre radius of the protected monument.
The Archaeological Department directed that construction be stopped because prior permission had not been obtained under the Maharashtra Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act.
The municipal council supported the petition challenging these directives.
Public Conveniences Excluded From Construction Restrictions
The petitioner and the municipal council relied on the Central Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, arguing that its definition of construction excludes facilities such as public latrines, urinals, drainage works and other public conveniences.
Accepting the need for such facilities, the High Court concluded that the proposed toilet block would serve a legitimate public purpose and contribute to maintaining cleanliness around the monument.
The Bench also examined the state’s reliance on a 1982 circular restricting the construction of toilet blocks near protected monuments.
Rejecting the argument that the circular justified stopping the project, the Court observed that substantial progress had been made in the country’s efforts to eliminate open defecation since 1982.
It held that heritage protection laws must be interpreted in light of changing circumstances and the need to provide basic public amenities.
In support of its observations, the Bench referred to a 2020 report of a NITI Aayog working group and a 2013 audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General, both of which highlighted deficiencies in toilet facilities at heritage locations.
Archaeological Department Directed To Decide Representation
While setting aside the October and November 2018 stop-work notices, the High Court directed the Assistant Director of the Archaeological Department in Aurangabad to decide a representation submitted in December 2018 seeking clearance for the proposed facility.
The authority must take a decision within two weeks after giving the dargah’s custodian and the Khuldabad Municipal Council an opportunity to be heard.
The Bench also clarified that the parties remained free to identify another mutually acceptable location for the toilet block if they wished.
