UPI PIN Authentication Alone Cannot Establish Customer Negligence: Consumer Commission Orders SBI to Pay Rs 85,000

The Telangana Consumer Commission has directed the State Bank of India (SBI) to pay Rs 85,000 to a woman who lost Rs 55,000 through an allegedly unauthorised UPI transaction, holding that the use of a UPI PIN does not automatically establish that an account holder authorised a payment or acted negligently.

In its November 10 order, the commission held that SBI had failed to establish that the complainant had either approved the disputed transaction or disclosed her confidential banking credentials. It also found deficiencies in the bank’s handling of her complaint despite receiving timely information about the alleged fraud.

The commission, comprising President Mamidi Christopher and members S Sandhya Rani and K Venkateshwarlu, ordered SBI to refund Rs 55,000, pay Rs 20,000 as compensation for deficiency in service and reimburse Rs 10,000 towards complaint costs.

Bank Must Establish Customer’s Role in Disputed Transaction

Rejecting SBI’s reliance on the authentication process, the commission observed that the use of a UPI PIN or other security mechanisms was not sufficient, by itself, to attribute responsibility for a disputed transaction to the customer.

READ ALSO  Consumer Commission Orders Marriage Bureau To Refund Fee And Pay Compensation After Nine-Year Delay

The bank was required to establish a factual basis demonstrating that the account holder had personally authorised the transfer or had been negligent in protecting her credentials.

The commission found insufficient evidence to conclude that the complainant had initiated the payment, consented to it or shared confidential information that enabled the transaction.

It also examined SBI’s response after the complaint was submitted and found that the bank had not demonstrated effective efforts to investigate the disputed transfer, coordinate with the beneficiary bank, secure the blocking or recovery of the money, or provide the complainant with a proper resolution.

The commission held that these failures amounted to deficiency in banking service.

Complaint Filed Within Three Working Days

A significant issue before the commission was whether the woman had reported the disputed transaction within the prescribed three-working-day period.

The 44-year-old complainant stated that Rs 55,000 had been transferred from her SBI account through UPI on November 3, 2022, without her knowledge or permission.

She reported the suspected cyber fraud on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal on November 6, 2022, and submitted a written complaint to her SBI branch on November 7. The bank acknowledged receiving the representation that day.

READ ALSO  Consumer Commission Holds MakeMyTrip Accountable for Booking Mishap, Orders Compensation

Although SBI argued that she had failed to report the transaction within the stipulated period, the commission disagreed.

Excluding Sunday, November 6, from the calculation, it treated November 7 as the third working day and concluded that the complaint had been submitted within the prescribed timeframe.

The woman subsequently approached the police, leading to the registration of an FIR on December 31, 2024.

SBI Denied Liability, Citing UPI Authentication

Represented by advocate G Krishna Reddy, SBI maintained that the disputed payment had passed through the required UPI authentication process, including verification through the UPI PIN and mobile/SIM-binding mechanism.

According to the bank, the transaction could not have been completed without the necessary authentication. It argued that customers were responsible for protecting their confidential credentials and that any transaction facilitated by their disclosure or negligence could not be attributed to the bank.

READ ALSO  ADR Moves to Supreme Court With Contempt Plea Over SBI's Failure to Disclose Electoral Bonds Data

SBI also denied any deficiency in service and disputed its liability to reimburse the amount.

The complainant, represented by advocate N Purnachandar, maintained that she had neither initiated the payment nor shared information permitting anyone else to authorise it. She alleged that the bank had failed to safeguard her account and address her grievance despite receiving the complaint.

Commission Awards Refund and Compensation

The commission observed that SBI, as a banking service provider, owed obligations to its account holder as a consumer of those services.

Considering the timely reporting of the disputed transaction, the absence of adequate evidence establishing customer negligence and the bank’s failure to demonstrate an effective response, it held SBI responsible for deficiency in service.

The commission consequently directed the bank to pay a total of Rs 85,000, comprising the disputed Rs 55,000 transaction amount, Rs 20,000 in compensation and Rs 10,000 in complaint costs.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles