The Supreme Court has held that an appellate court cannot set aside a trial court’s judgment merely because it suspects the plaintiff’s case, without weighing the truthfulness of the witnesses. With this ruling, the Court restored ₹8,70,000 in compensation awarded to a woman who lost her right hand after being electrocuted by a live wire.
A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar set aside a Rajasthan High Court judgment that had dismissed her compensation suit against Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (JVVNL).
Background
The suit was filed on behalf of the appellant, Rekha, who was a minor at the relevant time. She said that at around 7:00 AM on July 15, 2011, she was injured by electrocution because of the respondents’ negligence. According to her, the transmission lines running from village Phunthpura to village Harivansh ka Pura-Pathaur ka Pura had loosened and were hanging about 3-4 feet from the ground.
While passing through the village, she tried to ward off the wires, which turned out to be live. A major part of her body was badly burnt. She was later taken to Agra, where her right hand was amputated and she was left permanently handicapped. A Daily Diary Report was recorded at Basedi police station on August 18, 2011.
JVVNL called her story imaginary and concocted. It argued that anyone who came into contact with an 11 KV line would die on the spot, and it denied that any line was hanging low or that it had been negligent.
The trial court decreed the suit and awarded ₹8,70,000 with 6% interest. In S.B. Civil First Appeal No. 319 of 2016, the High Court reversed this decision on May 10, 2024. It found the incident suspicious and said the delay in reporting it fortified that suspicion. It remarked that “there is something which is unbelievable”.
Supreme Court’s Findings on Suspicion and Evidence
The Supreme Court held that the High Court committed serious errors in law and interfered with a well-considered judgment on mere ipse dixit. It observed, “A civil suit should be decided on the basis of evidence produced by the parties and not by merely raising a doubt on the claim made by the plaintiff.”
The Court noted that JVVNL’s only witness admitted in cross-examination that he had not witnessed the incident and was not on duty that day. He also admitted that maintaining the transmission lines was JVVNL’s responsibility. The Bench found that JVVNL’s defence turned out to be hearsay, while the appellant’s evidence “remained unshaken and intact.”
The Court held that the trial judge had applied the correct test of preponderance of probability. It said the High Court overlooked the rule that not every inconsistency or omission in a witness’s testimony is material in a civil trial.
The Court stated, “There is no provision in law which authorizes the Court to disbelieve the incident without recording a finding that the witnesses were unreliable or were found lying in the Court.”
It further held, “the appellate Court is not entitled to interfere with a judgment merely on the ground of suspicion without weighing truthfulness of the witnesses.”
The Bench added that a delay in lodging a claim or complaint, or some inconsistency in the plaintiff’s evidence, is no ground to set aside a judgment of a competent court. It observed, “The appellate Court should not embark upon a fault-finding expedition and interfere in the matter on mere showing of some mistake in the judgment under challenge.”
Outcome
The Supreme Court held that the High Court should not have interfered in a matter that attracts the respondents’ strict liability. It set aside the High Court’s order dated May 10, 2024, restored the trial court’s judgment and decree in Civil Case No. 02 of 2015, and allowed the appeal.
Case Title: Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited & Ors.
Case No.: Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (Civil) Diary No. 42323 of 2025
Bench: Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar
Date: November 16, 2026
