Consumer Commission Orders Builder to Pay Rs 2.10 Lakh for Defective House Construction

A consumer commission in Telangana has directed a builder to pay Rs 2.10 lakh to a 63-year-old retired government employee after finding deficiencies in the construction of his house. The commission held that defective doors, windows and poor-quality construction work had prevented the complainant from occupying the property.

In its October 30 order, the commission, comprising President G Nagaraju and member V Janardhan Reddy, awarded Rs 2 lakh towards repairs and replacement of defective woodwork and construction deficiencies, along with Rs 10,000 as costs.

The commission relied on reports submitted by a licensed engineer and an advocate commissioner, supported by photographs, which revealed defects in the construction. The inspection found that medium-quality materials had been used and that the door and window frames and shutters required replacement.

The builder also acknowledged during the proceedings that gaps existed between the windows and door shutters.

Commission Finds Deficiency in Service

After examining the evidence, the commission concluded that the builder had failed to deliver satisfactory construction work despite receiving payments from the complainant.

It observed that the defects and incomplete work had prevented the retired employee from moving into the house, establishing deficiency in service on the builder’s part.

READ ALSO  Consumer Commission Fines South Eastern Railway Rs 60,000 Over Five-Hour Delay

The commission also considered the complainant’s unwillingness to allow the same builder to undertake further work. It noted that he would have to incur additional expenses to complete the construction and rectify the defects.

Although no written agreement specified the scope of construction or its completion schedule, the commission found sufficient evidence to establish deficiencies in the work already undertaken.

Retired Employee Paid Rs 25.78 Lakh for Construction

The dispute arose after the complainant engaged the builder to construct the first and second floors of his residential property.

Initially, the arrangement covered the construction of pillars and a slab on the first floor, with payments to be released in two instalments upon completion of the respective stages.

Following completion of the first-floor slab, the builder proposed undertaking similar construction on the second floor and offered a discount of Rs 50,000 because the necessary equipment was already available at the premises.

READ ALSO  केरल में सिस्ट सर्जरी के बाद महिला की मौत: राष्ट्रीय उपभोक्ता आयोग ने मुआवजा बढ़ाकर 6 लाख रुपये किया, देखरेख में मानी गंभीर चूक

The complainant accepted the proposal, and work on the second-floor pillars began in November 2023.

According to the complaint, the retired employee paid a total of Rs 25.78 lakh to the builder on different occasions. However, he alleged that several portions remained unfinished and that the completed construction suffered from defects.

He subsequently sent letters seeking completion of the pending work and correction of the deficiencies. When the issues remained unresolved, he approached the consumer commission alleging deficiency in service.

Advocate D Prem Sagar represented the complainant.

Builder Blames Changes in Construction Requirements

Contesting the allegations, the builder maintained that the complainant repeatedly altered the agreed measurements and dimensions during construction.

Represented by advocate Lade Ramesh, the builder claimed that the complainant had instructed him to dismantle completed portions and undertake modifications, including replacement of tiles.

He also submitted that the construction arrangement was entirely oral because the property was registered in the complainant’s wife’s name and lacked valid building permission.

READ ALSO  Consumer Court Orders Syska to Compensate for Faulty Power Bank

The commission examined these submissions alongside the inspection findings and the complainant’s correspondence regarding defective and unfinished work.

Rs 2 Lakh Awarded for Repairs and Defective Work

The commission found that the inspection materials established unsatisfactory woodwork, including defective door and window frames and shutters.

It held the builder responsible for the deficiencies and directed him to pay Rs 2 lakh towards repairs to the doors, windows and shutters and the construction work carried out using inadequate-quality materials.

An additional Rs 10,000 was awarded towards costs, bringing the total amount payable to Rs 2.10 lakh.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles