State Cannot Keep Liquor Licences Suspended Indefinitely Without Valid Reasons: Calcutta High Court

The Calcutta High Court has directed the West Bengal government to permit liquor licence holders to operate their shops for the unexpired portion of their six-month temporary licences, holding that the state cannot prolong the suspension of such licences indefinitely without providing reasonable grounds.

A Division Bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray, in its November 13 order, held that although operating a liquor business is not a fundamental right, the privilege or legal right conferred through a licence cannot be withdrawn arbitrarily.

The Court found that the authorities had failed to establish any violation of licence conditions or other justification for continuing the suspension of the appellants’ licences after the 2019 Lok Sabha elections.

Suspension Continued Despite End Of Elections

The dispute arose after the West Bengal government introduced a new category of liquor licence in October 2018, permitting the sale of various types of liquor except tari and pachwai.

The appellants obtained temporary licences valid for six months after complying with the prescribed requirements and paying the necessary fees. They subsequently invested in infrastructure, made logistical arrangements and purchased liquor stocks for their businesses.

However, their shops were closed on March 2, 2019, following instructions attributed to the excise commissioner ahead of the Lok Sabha elections.

Although polling concluded and the election process ended on May 23, 2019, the suspension remained in force. The licence holders maintained that they had committed no violation warranting such action.

The suspension order was eventually revoked on August 22, 2019, but the affected businesses were not permitted to resume operations.

READ ALSO  SC Dismisses Plea Against Constitution of Delimitation Commission for Redrawing Constituencies in J-K

The dispute was further complicated when the state issued notifications on December 27, 2019, deleting the relevant category of liquor licence from the applicable rules.

Licence Holders Challenge Suspension And Denial Of Renewal

Senior Advocates Aninda Kr Mitra and Arindam Banerjee, representing the appellants, argued that obtaining a temporary liquor licence required considerable financial investment in infrastructure and operational arrangements.

They submitted that licence holders established their businesses with the expectation of securing regular licences upon complying with the applicable rules.

The appellants questioned the excise commissioner’s authority to suspend their licences, contending that the power to issue suspension orders rested with the collector. They also maintained that the general elections did not constitute a lawful ground for suspending the licences.

According to their submissions, no material had been produced to establish that the excise commissioner had issued any valid instruction authorising the suspension.

The licence holders clarified that they were not asserting a fundamental right to trade in liquor. Instead, they sought enforcement of their legal rights concerning licence renewal.

Opposing the appeal, Advocate Shiv Sankar Banerjee, appearing for the state government, submitted that citizens had no fundamental right to demand the grant, renewal or continuation of licences for manufacturing, selling or distributing liquor.

He argued that automatic renewal was impermissible under the law and that the temporary licences had already expired through the passage of time. Consequently, they could neither be revived nor extended.

State Must Justify Indefinite Suspension

READ ALSO  Calcutta High Court To Hear Trinamool Faction's Plea For Esplanade Rally On July 15

Examining the statutory framework, the High Court observed that the Bengal Excise Act, 1909, and the rules framed under it prescribed specific circumstances in which temporary licences could be suspended or cancelled.

The Bench found that the suspension order did not identify the statutory provision under which the authorities had acted, despite the excise commissioner possessing certain powers under the Act.

The Court acknowledged that restrictions on liquor sales during designated dry days could be imposed to maintain public peace and tranquillity. However, it found no explanation for continuing the suspension after the elections had concluded.

It held that even where the government possessed the authority to suspend or cancel temporary licences, the exercise of that power had to be supported by reasonable grounds, particularly when the suspension continued for an indefinite period.

The Bench further observed that fairness in administrative action must be assessed against established legal principles, which form part of the constitutional framework.

The judges rejected the state’s contention that the appellants’ licences could simply be treated as expired because the original six-month period had elapsed.

READ ALSO  Delhi High Court to Hear Plea for Enhanced Compensation for HIV-Positive Sexual Assault Survivor

According to the Court, accepting such an argument despite the absence of any demonstrated default by the licence holders would effectively allow arbitrary state action to prevail over lawful conduct.

The Bench held that the authorities could not deprive the appellants of their licensed business activities merely by allowing the validity period to expire while keeping the licences suspended without justification.

High Court Directs State To Permit Business Operations

Allowing relief to the appellants, the High Court directed the West Bengal government to permit them to operate their liquor shops for the remaining duration of their original six-month licence periods.

The direction was intended to enable the licence holders to dispose of the liquor stocks accumulated in their establishments during the prolonged closure.

The ruling reaffirmed that while the trade in liquor does not enjoy protection as a fundamental right, statutory privileges granted by the government must be regulated through lawful, reasonable and non-arbitrary administrative action.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles