Supreme Court Stays Andhra HC Order Faulting CBI Director in Tirumala Temple Ghee Adulteration Probe


The Supreme Court on Friday stayed an Andhra Pradesh High Court order that criticised the CBI director for permitting an officer outside the court-appointed special investigation team (SIT) to assist in the probe into allegations of adulterated ghee being used in the famed Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanamโ€™s laddu prasadam.

A bench headed by Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justice K. Vinod Chandran granted interim relief on the plea of the CBI director, holding there was no impropriety if the probe agency chief, while monitoring the case, allowed an officer to support the SIT.
“If SIT wants to appoint a particular officer, what is wrong with that?” the bench asked.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the CBI, defended the directorโ€™s decision, submitting that he had personally convened a meeting with SIT members, reviewed the case, and permitted officer J. Venkat Rao to continue in a limited role. โ€œHe is only a record keeper,โ€ Mehta said.

READ ALSO  Delhi Police seeks cancellation of case filed by minor against WFI Chief

The submission was strongly opposed by the respondentโ€™s counsel, who argued that an investigating officer (IO) cannot be reduced to a mere record keeper and alleged that Rao had in fact coerced the complainant into making forced confessions.

The controversy stemmed from a petition filed by Kaduru Chinnappanna, who alleged harassment and duress by Rao, including videographed statements dictated under pressure. The Andhra Pradesh High Court had ruled that the CBI directorโ€™s action violated the Supreme Courtโ€™s earlier order of 2024, which mandated an independent SIT comprising:

  • Two CBI officers nominated by the CBI director,
  • Two officers from the Andhra Pradesh Police nominated by the state, and
  • One senior officer from the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI).
READ ALSO  Supreme Court to Frame Nationwide Guidelines to Strengthen Security in Trial Courts After Rising Violence in Premises

Since Rao was not formally nominated as a member of this SIT, the High Court concluded he could not exercise investigative powers.

The CJI, however, questioned whether the SIT had truly abdicated its jurisdiction by allowing Raoโ€™s involvement, noting that appointing an officer to assist did not necessarily override SIT supervision. When the respondentโ€™s counsel alleged coercion, the bench advised, โ€œYou make a complaint.โ€

Staying the High Courtโ€™s order, the Supreme Court directed the respondent to file a reply to the CBI directorโ€™s plea. The matter will now proceed on merits.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles