Jharkhand High Court Grants Bail to Constable Accused of JPSC Exam Manipulation, Questions Absence of Regular State Counsel

The Jharkhand High Court has granted bail to a police constable accused of paying Rs 10 lakh to manipulate his performance in a Jharkhand Public Service Commission (JPSC) examination, finding that the material before the court consisted only of confessional statements made by the accused and a co-accused.

Justice Anil Kumar Choudhary, in an order dated November 5, also expressed concern over the absence of regular State counsel during the hearing of the bail application, describing the prosecution’s handling of the matter as a “sorry state of affairs”.

The court observed that no material apart from the confessional statements had been presented to establish the constable’s alleged involvement. Considering that the chargesheet had already been filed before the trial court, it found the case appropriate for granting bail.

High Court Questions State’s Representation

During the proceedings, the High Court took exception to the failure of regular State counsel to appear in what it considered an important case.

READ ALSO  Calcutta High Court Directs State Government to Transfer Darivit High School Violence Case to NIA

The court recorded that an assistant counsel to the State counsel appeared only when the order was being dictated. The assistant counsel then sought permission to leave for another court, citing his busy schedule.

Justice Choudhary expressed dissatisfaction with the manner in which the State and prosecution had handled their representation before the court. Despite seeking permission to leave, the assistant counsel opposed the constable’s bail application.

Allegations of Payment to Manipulate Examination Results

The prosecution alleged that the constable had paid Rs 10 lakh to a co-accused to secure manipulation of his performance in the JPSC examination.

As part of the alleged arrangement, he had reportedly handed over his original educational certificates and copies of his OMR answer sheets.

The November 5 order also referred to a statement allegedly made by the constable before the police. According to that statement, the co-accused had instructed him to answer only those examination questions for which he knew the answers and leave the remaining questions unanswered.

READ ALSO  Important Cases Heard in Supreme Court on Tuesday 31st January 2023

The constable had been serving in the police force since June 2017.

Defence Disputes Allegations, Cites Lack of Evidence

Advocates Yashvardhan and Ritesh Singh, representing the constable, maintained that the allegations against their client were false and pointed out that he had not been named in the FIR.

They argued that the prosecution had no independent evidence establishing his involvement apart from the confessional statement of the co-accused.

The defence also placed details of the constable’s educational background before the court, including his schooling, college education and the different stages of the JPSC examination that he had cleared.

Seeking bail, the advocates submitted that the constable had remained in custody since August 6. They assured the court that he would cooperate with the trial and would neither disturb nor harass prosecution witnesses.

READ ALSO  Jharkhand High Court Fines BIT Mesra ₹20 Lakh Over Student’s Murder, Issues Safety Guidelines for Educational Institutes

Chargesheet Already Filed, Court Finds Bail Appropriate

After examining the submissions and available material, the High Court found that the confessional statements of the constable and the co-accused were the only material placed before it to indicate his alleged involvement.

The court also considered that the investigation had progressed to the stage where the chargesheet had already been submitted before the trial court.

In these circumstances, Justice Choudhary allowed the constable’s bail application.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles