Delhi High Court Upholds Acquittal in Rape Case, Says Evidence Showed Strong Possibility but Lacked Corroboration

The Delhi High Court has upheld the acquittal of a man accused of raping a young woman who died by suicide before she could testify at trial, holding that although the material on record indicated a strong possibility of rape, the prosecution case could not be sufficiently corroborated in her absence.

Justice Vimal Kumar Yadav was hearing the Stateโ€™s appeal against the 2009 acquittal. The court examined the womanโ€™s statements to the police and a magistrate, her death note, medical evidence and the testimony of family members.

The case related to an alleged incident in May 2006 at the womanโ€™s jhuggi in Delhi. According to the prosecution, the accused, who was her neighbour, entered the jhuggi while she was alone, bolted the door and raped her.

READ ALSO  เค†เคคเค‚เค• เคซเค‚เคกเคฟเค‚เค— เค•เฅ‡เคธ: เคธเฅˆเคฏเคฆ เคธเคฒเคพเคนเฅเคฆเฅเคฆเฅ€เคจ เค•เฅ‡ เคฌเฅ‡เคŸเฅ‹เค‚ เค•เฅ€ เคฏเคพเคšเคฟเค•เคพเคเค‚ เคฆเคฟเคฒเฅเคฒเฅ€ เคนเคพเคˆ เค•เฅ‹เคฐเฅเคŸ เคจเฅ‡ เค•เฅ€ เค–เคพเคฐเคฟเคœ

The woman later informed her brother about the alleged assault, following which an FIR for rape was registered. Her statement was subsequently recorded before a magistrate and she underwent a medical examination.

Around three months after the alleged incident, and before she could appear as a witness in court, the woman ended her life. Her note stated that she had taken the step because of the shame associated with the incident.

Court Notes Vulnerability Faced By Women

While considering the appeal, the High Court observed that women, particularly young girls, remain vulnerable and may face exploitation even at the hands of people known to them, including neighbours and relatives.

The court also said the impact of rape was not confined to physical violation and could extend deeply into a survivorโ€™s psychological and mental well-being.

It further noted that survivors may face stigma, ostracisation and questions about their character instead of receiving sympathy, empathy and support.

According to the court, the absence of family, medical, psychological and social support can make life extremely difficult for a survivor and may discourage her from pursuing legal remedies.

The September 28 order also referred to the trauma involved in recounting an alleged sexual assault before investigating agencies and courts and then undergoing cross-examination.

READ ALSO  HC Slaps Cost of 50K in PIL, alleging misusing of public money, based on a tweet

Trial Court Had Acquitted Accused In 2009

The trial court had examined 18 prosecution witnesses before acquitting the accused in 2009.

Challenging that decision, the State argued before the High Court that the womanโ€™s statements, her death note, medical material and the testimony of her family members were sufficient to establish the prosecution case.

The accused, however, opposed the appeal on the ground that the womanโ€™s testimony was not available for examination before the trial court. He also pointed to contradictions in the remaining evidence and argued that there was no conclusive scientific material linking him to the alleged offence.

READ ALSO  เคฆเคฟเคฒเฅเคฒเฅ€ เคนเคพเคˆเค•เฅ‹เคฐเฅเคŸ เคจเฅ‡ เคชเฅ‚เคฐเฅเคต เคกเฅ€เคฏเฅ‚เคเคธเคฏเฅ‚ เค…เคงเฅเคฏเค•เฅเคท เคฐเฅ‹เคจเค• เค–เคคเฅเคฐเฅ€ เค•เฅ‹ เคฎเคฟเคฒเฅ€ เคงเคฎเค•เคฟเคฏเฅ‹เค‚ เคชเคฐ เคชเฅเคฒเคฟเคธ เค•เฅ‹ เคธเฅเคฐเค•เฅเคทเคพ เคชเฅเคฐเคฆเคพเคจ เค•เคฐเคจเฅ‡ เค•เฅ‡ เคจเคฟเคฐเฅเคฆเฅ‡เคถ เคฆเคฟเค

After considering the record, the High Court found that the evidence created a strong possibility that rape had taken place but held that this could not be adequately corroborated after the womanโ€™s death. It therefore declined to interfere with the acquittal.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles