The Calcutta High Court on Thursday refused to grant interim protection against coercive action to Sumit Roy, an aide to Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee, in four criminal cases, noting that he was already in custody and could seek relief under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
Justice Sougata Bhattacharyya held that Roy’s request for interim relief had lost significance because he had already been arrested in one case and subsequently shown as arrested in three others.
Roy had approached the High Court seeking a stay on further proceedings in all four cases, along with an order preventing the authorities from taking coercive steps against him.
Existing Arrests Weighed Against Interim Relief
The court observed that Roy’s plea might have warranted different consideration had he not already been in custody in the case registered at Salboni police station in Paschim Medinipur district.
Roy was arrested on September 10 in connection with allegations involving an illegal land deal. He was subsequently shown as arrested in three additional criminal cases.
Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Majumdar, representing the West Bengal government, informed the court that Roy’s arrest followed the Supreme Court’s rejection of his anticipatory bail application.
Majumdar further submitted that Roy had already been shown as arrested in the remaining three cases before he approached the High Court seeking interim protection.
Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for Roy, expressed concern that the police could take coercive action against his client in connection with the four cases unless the High Court intervened.
However, Justice Bhattacharyya declined to grant protection at this stage, pointing to Roy’s existing custody and the alternative legal remedies available under the BNSS.
State Directed to File Response Within Three Weeks
While declining immediate relief, the High Court directed the state authorities to file their affidavits in opposition within three weeks.
Roy has been given one additional week to submit his reply after receiving the state’s affidavits.
The court also permitted Roy’s counsel to mention the matter before the appropriate bench once the exchange of affidavits is complete.
