Registrar’s Power To Substitute Deceased Trade Mark Applicant Is A Power Coupled With Duty, Registration To Dead Person Prima Facie Illegal: Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court has held that the Trade Marks Registrar’s power to substitute a deceased applicant with a successor is a power coupled with a duty. It also held that granting a trade mark registration to a dead person is, prima facie, per se illegal. Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan dismissed a rectification petition by Varun Atulya Mafatlal over the ‘SUNGRACE MAFATLAL’ device marks as barred by limitation. However, the Court initiated suo motu rectification proceedings under Section 57(4) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which may lead to the marks being deleted from the Register altogether.

Background

Madhuri Mafatlal applied in 2011 to register the ‘SUNGRACE MAFATLAL’ device marks in Class 24 and Class 25. She died on July 15, 2013. In December 2015, her daughter Malavika Taktawala informed the Registrar of her death. Malavika relied on Madhuri’s Will and claimed the marks as a legatee under the Will of Madhuri’s son, Ajay, who had died in August 2015. Neither Will has been probated. No order was ever passed on these 2015 applications.

Even so, the marks were registered in Madhuri’s name in May and August 2017. On July 5, 2018, the Registrar recorded Malavika as subsequent proprietor without notice to other relatives. The next day, Malavika assigned the marks to Shree Vallabh Chandak for ₹9 lakh each. Chandak was recorded as proprietor on September 17, 2018.

Varun, Madhuri’s grandson and the son of Atulya Mafatlal, who died in September 2022, said he learnt of the entries in August 2023. He filed the petition in December 2023 seeking deletion of the entries in favour of Malavika and Chandak. In July 2025, after Chandak raised limitation, he also sought condonation of a delay of 557 days, as computed by him.

Arguments

Senior Advocates Veerendra Tulzapurkar and Ashish Kamat, appearing for Varun, argued that there was no delay because time ran only from his discovery of the fraud under Section 17 of the Limitation Act. They submitted that the marks had been registered in the name of a dead person and transferred on the basis of unprobated Wills, without notice to the heirs and without any speaking order.

READ ALSO  Erroneous Decision Can Operate as Res judicata Between Parties: Karnataka HC

Senior Advocate Sharan Jagtiani, appearing for Chandak, argued that the petition was hopelessly time-barred. He submitted that Varun inherited his father’s limitation clock and that the entries in the Register were notice to the world. He also argued that Rule 55 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017 is only directory, and that Chandak is a bona fide assignee for value.

Advocate Nikhil Kumar Rungta, appearing for Malavika, submitted that she held a bona fide belief of title under the Wills and that the Registrar knew of the deaths. The Registrar did not appear.

Grandson’s petition barred by limitation

The Court held that Varun is a “person aggrieved”, as a member of the Mafatlal family and given that the marks are founded on the family surname. But it held that he can claim only through Atulya. Time under Article 137 began running when the entries were made in July and September 2018, and expired in 2021 while Atulya was alive. The Court noted that Madhuri’s applications were advertised in 2016 and 2017, and the renewals in 2020, yet Atulya did nothing.

The Court held: “The cause of action to seek rectification cannot spring back to life from scratch for every successive generation, claiming to have discovered the cause of action”. It found no sufficient cause to condone the delay.

READ ALSO  No Claim For Appointment Survives Once Life of Waiting List Expires: Allahabad HC

Rule 55: a power coupled with duty

The Court said the matter could not end there, because “Integrity of the Register of Trade Marks can only be ensured by the integrity of due process followed by the Registrar.”

It noted that Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules and Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules provide for substituting a successor when an applicant dies before registration, on proof of death and of transmission of interest. Rejecting Chandak’s argument that these rules are merely enabling, the Court held that the provision “entails a power coupled with duty to be satisfied with proof to process the application of a dead person any further.”

Chandak had also argued that a registration relates back to the date of the application. The Court called this contention disingenuous, observing that it “makes a mockery of the need for an existing live person to be a “proprietor” of a mark proposed to be registered.” It added: “A dead person cannot sustain an application.”

The Court also noted that Madhuri’s Will refers only to the Class 24 mark. It questioned how the Class 25 mark could have passed to Malavika and then to Chandak.

READ ALSO  Removing a person from job only because he is blind is a violation of the Person With Disability Act

Suo motu rectification initiated

On Chandak’s argument that suo motu rectification is available only where a registration is per se illegal, the Court observed: “Prima facie, granting registration of a trade mark to a dead person falls in that category.”

The Court directed notice to Chandak, Malavika and Madhuri’s estate, through the two executors named in her Will. They must show cause why the 2017 registration should not be cancelled, and why the effect of the registration should not be stayed in the meantime. They must also explain how the Class 25 mark came to be assigned to Chandak.

The Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks has been directed to have a senior officer who has not handled the case examine the files from 2011 onwards. That officer must file an affidavit explaining the Registry’s conduct. The affidavit must also cover the Registry’s procedure for applicants who die before registration, and data on registrations granted to persons known to be dead in the past ten years. Replies and the affidavit are due by January 15, 2027, and the suo motu petition will be listed on January 20, 2027.

Case Title: Varun Atulya Mafatlal v. Shree Vallabh Chandak & Ors.

Case No.: Commercial Miscellaneous Petition No. 27 of 2024 (with Interim Application No. 3462 of 2025)

Bench: Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan

Date: November 19, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles