Supreme Court Issues Notice to Centre on Health Risks of Consanguineous Marriages, Says It Cannot Direct Legislation

The Supreme Court has issued notice to the Union government on a petition seeking safeguards against the health risks associated with marriages between close blood relatives, while making it clear that decisions concerning legislation fall within Parliament’s domain.

A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana limited the notice to asking the Centre to consider whether suitable legislation was desirable or whether greater public awareness could address the issue.

The petition was filed by a 20-year-old law student who raised concerns about the potential health consequences of consanguineous marriages, particularly for future generations.

The Court clarified that it was not directing the government to enact any law. Instead, it sought to draw the Centre’s attention to the need for public education about the possible genetic and health risks associated with such marriages.

Supreme Court Emphasises Legislative Authority

During the hearing, the bench observed that regulating marriage customs through legislation was a matter for the legislature rather than the judiciary.

The petitioner’s counsel clarified that the plea did not seek a judicial direction compelling Parliament to legislate. Instead, the petitioner wanted safeguards within the existing legal framework to address the health consequences of consanguineous marriages.

READ ALSO  सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने जयप्रकाश एसोसिएट्स के ₹14,535 करोड़ के अधिग्रहण पर रोक लगाने से किया इनकार; 10 अप्रैल को होगी अंतिम सुनवाई

Counsel also submitted that data indicated the prevalence of such marriages could be as high as 28% in southern states.

The bench referred to earlier Supreme Court rulings concerning marriages involving HIV-positive individuals to emphasise that choosing a spouse is a matter of personal autonomy.

According to the Court, individuals must be free to make informed decisions about marriage, and judicial intervention cannot replace personal choice by imposing mandatory restrictions.

The judges also observed that the law already provides remedies in situations where consent to marriage is not properly informed.

Court Discusses Public Awareness and Scientific Temper

The petition raised concerns about intergenerational equity, arguing that the health consequences of marriages between close relatives could affect children born from such unions.

During the discussion, the bench noted that such marriages frequently occurred in rural communities where families might not fully understand the associated health risks. The petitioner’s counsel pointed out that the practice was also prevalent in urban areas.

The Court considered public education as a possible response and referred to the constitutional duty under Article 51A(h) to develop scientific temper.

READ ALSO  Dishonour of Post-dated Cheques Not Sufficient to Prove Cheating in High-Risk Ventures Without Initial Dishonest Intent: Supreme Court

The petitioner’s counsel suggested involving Anganwadi centres and Panchayats in awareness initiatives to help families understand the possible consequences of consanguineous marriages.

The bench also indicated that schools and colleges could play an important role by incorporating relevant scientific information into educational curricula.

Notice Limited to Legislation or Awareness Measures

The Supreme Court ultimately issued notice to the Union government for two specific purposes.

First, the Centre may consider the desirability of introducing suitable legislation addressing the concerns raised in the petition.

Alternatively, it may examine ways to ensure widespread awareness of the health risks associated with consanguineous marriages through public outreach, educational programmes and appropriate school and college curricula.

READ ALSO  Supreme Court Overturns Karnataka High Court's Decision in Illegal Iron Ore Export Case

The Court reiterated that its notice should not be understood as a direction to Parliament to enact legislation or as an attempt to judicially regulate marriage customs.

During the proceedings, counsel also informed the bench that the petitioner experienced immunity-related health issues and had a 40% visual impairment but was continuing her legal education.

The matter will now proceed on the limited question of whether legislative consideration or public awareness measures are appropriate to address the concerns raised.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles