Excise Duty Evasion Without Violence, Threat Or Coercion Does Not Make Accused A “Gang” Under UP Gangsters Act: Allahabad High Court

The Allahabad High Court has held that alleged excise duty evasion, without any violence, threat, intimidation or coercion, does not amount to the activity of a “gang” under the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986. A Bench of Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena quashed a Gangsters Act FIR registered in Saharanpur against four petitioners, along with the gang chart on which it rested. The Court also issued directions on how gang charts must be prepared and approved across the State.

Background

On 03.03.2021, a joint team of the Excise Department and the Special Task Force intercepted a truck carrying 1,500 cases of country liquor from a licensed unit at Yusufpur Tapri, Saharanpur. The allegation was that the same pass and bar code were used for a second trip, so duty was paid on one consignment while two were removed. FIRs were registered under the U.P. Excise Act and the IPC. The State SIT filed ten charge-sheets between 2021 and 2024, and the trial is pending before the Special Judge, P.C. Act, CBI (Central), Lucknow. Each petitioner is on bail.

In 2023, a committee chaired by the Principal Secretary (Home) recommended Gangsters Act action against nine persons. In December 2025, the police prepared a gang chart naming 27 persons, which the District Magistrate approved on 09.12.2025. FIR No. 645 of 2025 was registered the same night. Pranay Aneja was shown as the gang leader, and Ashwani Upadhyay, Upendra Govind Rao and former Excise Inspector Ravindra Kishor as members.

READ ALSO  Any Qualification Attained During the Pendency of Writ Petition Would Not condone the Fraud: Allahabad HC

Arguments

Senior Counsel Purnendu Chakravarty, assisted by Advocate Rishabh Chauhan, appeared for the petitioners. He argued that the Supreme Court in Shiv Pratap Singh v. State of U.P. had held that the Act creates no offence. He also submitted that the allegations disclosed no violence or coercion, and that the gang chart was approved without application of mind. He further argued that the Act was invoked over a single 2021 incident, shortly after a judgment adverse to the Excise Department.

The Additional Government Advocate, appearing for the State, argued that a single offence is enough to invoke the Act. He also submitted that the constitutional validity of the Act was left open in Shiv Pratap Singh, and that a joint meeting had in fact been held.

Act still operative, but no “gang” made out

The Court held that Shiv Pratap Singh did not decide the constitutionality of the Act. The Full Bench ruling in Ashok Kumar Dixit v. State of U.P., which upheld the Act, continues to bind the Bench. The Act therefore remains operative.

However, the Court found that no act of violence, threat, intimidation or coercion was attributed to any petitioner. It observed that “Employees who act within a hierarchy, on the instructions of their superiors and in the course of a company’s business, do not become a gang merely because that business is alleged to have been run unlawfully.” It held that Shraddha Gupta v. State of U.P., relied on by the State, itself requires these means and this object.

READ ALSO  Staff Shortage Cannot Be Ground To Deny Child Care Leave To Eligible Employee: Chhattisgarh High Court

The Bench noted that the only incident took place on 03.03.2021, and that nothing was alleged against any petitioner in the four years and nine months that followed. It said it was recording no finding of mala fides. But the gang chart came soon after the High Court’s 10.10.2025 ruling in the company’s licence case, and the Court found no reasons on record for invoking the Act at that moment.

Gang chart approved without application of mind

The Court found that no minutes of the joint meeting were on record. On the District Magistrate’s approval “on the basis of consensus”, it observed: “Consensus means that the officers agreed. It says nothing about any examination of the material.”

The Circle Officer, the Nodal Officer and the Superintendent of Police had each written the same three sentences. The Bench remarked: “When every tier repeats the tier below it, there is in truth only one tier.” It also noted that 20 persons were added beyond the SIT’s list without any reason, and that several endorsements were undated.

Directions

The Court observed that “A law carrying graver consequences than the ordinary penal law is an exception to the ordinary process, and not an alternative to it.” It issued 12 directions for future cases, including:

  • individual satisfaction for each person named in a gang chart;
  • recorded reasons why the ordinary prosecution is inadequate;
  • the date of the last act attributed to each person;
  • written minutes of the joint meeting;
  • dated satisfaction recorded in each officer’s own words;
  • no FIR before approval and minutes are complete.
READ ALSO  Sec 498A: An Apology should be tempered with genuine remorse and repentance, and not a calculated strategy to avoid punishment: Jharkhand HC

Outcome

The writ petitions were allowed, and the FIR, gang chart and all consequential proceedings were quashed against the four petitioners. The Court clarified that the pending trial, the PMLA proceedings and any departmental proceedings against Ravindra Kishor will continue unaffected. A copy of the judgment is to be sent to the Chief Secretary and the Additional Chief Secretary (Home) within two weeks, for circulation to all District Magistrates and police chiefs.

Case Title: Pranay Aneja v. State of U.P. and 4 Others (with connected petitions)

Case No.: Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 29359 of 2025 (with Nos. 29357, 29358 and 29994 of 2025)

Bench: Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena

Date: November 19, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles