No Interim Protection to Restaurants Against Service Charge Ban: Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court on Thursday clarified that restaurants challenging the prohibition on mandatory service charges have not been granted any interim protection, even as it admitted appeals filed by two major hospitality associations against an earlier judgement upholding the ban.

A Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma made the clarification after the Centre raised concerns that some restaurants continued to impose service charges despite the March 28, 2025 ruling of a single judge declaring the practice an unfair trade practice.

The Bench admitted appeals filed by the National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and the Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI), directing that they be heard in the regular course.

Pending Appeals Do Not Amount to Interim Relief

Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma, representing the Centre, informed the court that certain restaurants were continuing to collect service charges despite the adverse judgement.

He submitted that restaurants might rely on the pendency or admission of their appeals to justify continuing the practice, although their requests for interim protection had not been granted.

The Bench clarified that no interim relief had been issued in favour of the restaurant associations. It also indicated that the government was free to take appropriate action against violations rather than expecting the court to initiate enforcement.

READ ALSO  उपभोक्ता अदालत ने ट्रेन में लूटे गए और चाकू मारे गए यात्री को मुआवज़ा देने को कहा

Sharma maintained that the continued collection of mandatory service charges by some establishments was affecting consumers despite the existing judicial ruling.

Service Charge Cannot Be Treated as Voluntary Tip

The hearing also addressed the distinction between service charges and tips paid by customers.

The Bench questioned why restaurants collected service charges separately instead of incorporating the amount into food prices.

Counsel representing the associations explained that separately displaying the charge ensured transparency and allowed customers to identify the amount intended for staff welfare.

The associations also maintained that the practice had existed for years and had evolved from the traditional system of customers giving cash tips to waiters.

The court, however, distinguished the two practices, observing that tipping in India remained a matter of customer discretion and could not be equated with a mandatory charge. It also noted that India had no legislation requiring customers to pay a fixed percentage of their restaurant bills as tips.

Challenge to CCPA Guidelines

READ ALSO  Persons With Disabilities Entitled To Horizontal Reservation Cutting Across All Categories: Uttarakhand HC

The appeals arise from the single judge’s March 28, 2025 judgement dismissing petitions filed by the restaurant associations against guidelines issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA).

The guidelines prohibit hotels and restaurants from automatically or mandatorily adding service charges to food bills.

Upholding the guidelines, the single judge held that imposing service charges in a concealed or coercive manner constituted an unfair trade practice under consumer protection law.

The judgement also found that compulsory service charges operated against public interest and adversely affected consumers. It observed that customers faced an additional financial burden when Goods and Services Tax was imposed on bills containing service charges.

The single judge had imposed costs of ₹1 lakh each on the NRAI and FHRAI, directing that the amounts be deposited with the CCPA for consumer welfare.

Restaurant Associations Question Legal Basis of Ban

READ ALSO  ₹2000 Currency Notes Should Only Be Deposited in Bank Accounts: Seeks Plea Filed in Delhi HC

In its appeal, the NRAI has raised questions concerning the interpretation of unfair trade practices under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

One of its principal arguments concerns whether a service charge can be classified as an unfair trade practice when restaurants expressly disclose it on menu cards and display the information within their establishments.

The NRAI states that it represents approximately 7,000 restaurants nationwide, including 2,500 member outlets in Delhi-NCR.

The FHRAI claims to represent the interests of around 55,000 hotels and five lakh restaurants across India.

With the appeals now admitted, the dispute over the legality of mandatory service charges will be examined by the Division Bench. However, the High Court has made clear that the admission of the appeals does not suspend the operation of the single judge’s judgement.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles