The Delhi High Court has held that the wife of a judgment debtor cannot obstruct the execution of a decree that has attained finality merely by claiming settled possession, without material to show an independent right in the property.
Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar dismissed an appeal filed by a woman against the order of an Executing Court that had rejected her objections to the execution of a decree passed against her husband.
Background
The dispute arose between two brothers over a shop that, the appellant said, had been bought by their father. One brother filed a suit against the other, the appellant’s husband, seeking possession, mesne profits and a permanent injunction for a shop in Shiv Puri Extension, Delhi. The Trial Court decreed the suit in his favour on May 4, 2023.
When the decree holder started execution proceedings, the appellant filed objections. She claimed she was in settled possession of the shop, that it had been bought by her father-in-law and never partitioned, and that the decree had been obtained by fraud. The District Judge-01, Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, dismissed her objections on January 30, 2026, and she appealed to the High Court.
Her husband did not challenge the decree and did not file any objections in the execution proceedings.
Arguments
Advocate Shruti Munjal, along with Advocates Gurmehar Singh and Aditya, appeared for the appellant. She argued that the appellant was not a party to the suit and could not be bound by the decree merely because she was the judgment debtor’s wife. She submitted that the appellant’s objections had to be decided under Order XXI Rules 97 to 101 of the CPC, since she had asserted an independent claim to possession.
Munjal said that an electricity receipt in the appellant’s name was relied on as proof of possession, not ownership. She cited the Supreme Court’s rulings in Periyammal (Dead) through LRs v. V. Rajamani, Brahmdeo Chaudhary v. Rishikesh Prasad Jaiswal and Silverline Forum Pvt. Ltd. v. Rajiv Trust. She also relied on the decree holder’s earlier statement in another suit that the shop had been bought by his late father.
No one appeared for the respondents.
Court’s Findings
The Court noted that the decree was passed in a contested suit and had attained finality. It held that the electricity receipt “at its highest, is only corroborative material and does not, by itself, establish either an independent right in the subject premises or possession independent of the Judgment Debtor.”
Accepting that an executing court must decide claims of persons resisting execution under Order XXI, the Court said “the statutory protection available to a third-party objector cannot be construed as enabling a person to obstruct execution merely by asserting an independent claim without placing any substantive material in support thereof.” It held that the Supreme Court rulings cited do not remove the need for the objector to establish a bona fide independent claim.
The Court rejected the reliance on the earlier suit, noting that the decree holder’s statement there concerned Shop No. 2, while the decree under execution concerns Shop No. 3. On the fraud allegation, it observed: “Fraud, being a serious allegation, cannot be accepted on the basis of mere inconsistencies alleged in the stands taken by a party in different proceedings.”
The Court held that the appellant could not indirectly reopen issues already decided between the parties to the suit, stating: “The mere assertion of possession, unsupported by material demonstrating an independent possessory interest, cannot furnish a ground to indefinitely obstruct execution of a decree which has attained finality.”
Finding no perversity, illegality or material infirmity in the Executing Court’s order, the High Court dismissed the appeal along with the pending applications.
Case Title: Anamika Mishra v. Krishan Kumar Mishra & Anr.
Case No.: EX.F.A. 69/2026
Bench: Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar
Date: November 18, 2026
