The Allahabad High Court has ordered a man to be taken into custody after he was found recording court proceedings on his mobile phone without permission. It has also directed that litigants will not be allowed to bring mobile phones into courtrooms.
Justice Vikram D. Chauhan observed that open justice does not amount to a “free broadcast” by unauthorised persons. The Court held that no one has the right to record court proceedings without its leave.
What Happened in Court
During the hearing, Additional Government Advocate P.K. Singh told the Court that a man was recording the proceedings on his mobile phone without permission. The man, who identified himself as Raj Kulshrestha, admitted to recording the hearing but could not give any reason for it.
The Bench Secretary took his phone into custody and found three videos of the court proceedings on it. The Court noted that Kulshrestha had no case listed before it. He had entered the courtroom with a pass that only allowed access to the advocates’ chambers.
Kuldeep Batra, the petitioner in a case listed at Serial No. 27, was also found in the courtroom with the same kind of pass. Batra told the Court he did not know Kulshrestha.
Kulshrestha told the Court that Advocate Bhanu Pratap Seth, a junior of Advocate Nitish Kumar Soni, had brought him to court. The Court was told that Soni was out of station, and Seth was absent when the matter was taken up.
Bar Association Objects
Senior Advocate C.P. Upadhyaya, President of the High Court Bar Association, told the Court that some advocates were recording and uploading videos of court proceedings, which he said was against the decorum of the Court. He placed on record the Association’s notice of November 18, 2026, which bans making videos, reels and photographs in courtrooms and corridors. Under the notice, anyone caught doing so must pay a ₹5,000 fine, and advocates may face disciplinary action, including termination of their Association membership.
Court’s Observations
The Court noted that it hears criminal matters, including cases on personal liberty, child sexual abuse, and CBI, Enforcement Directorate and MP/MLA matters. It said the facts of these cases need not be published on social media before the Court decides them.
On open justice, the Court observed: “The principle of open justice means proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, the same does not amount to “free broadcast” by any unauthorized individual.”
It added that litigants’ personal details should not be broadcast and discussed on social media, because “the court proceedings are not for entertainment purpose but is a serious business affecting liberty and rights of an individual.”
The Court warned that such recordings “may have the effect of social media trial without even the final determination in the court proceedings”. It said they could cause prejudice to litigants and expose victims to social media stigma. It held that broadcasting must be regulated by the presiding officer of each court and that “no person has the right to record the court proceedings except with the leave of the Court.”
Directions
The Court ordered Kulshrestha to be taken into custody and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, after a medical examination. The CJM may release him on bail if he furnishes a personal bond and two sureties, on condition that he appears before the High Court on November 20, 2026. He must explain why he recorded the proceedings without leave and why this should not be treated as interference in the administration of justice. His phone will be kept in a sealed cover and produced in court.
Advocates Nitish Kumar Soni and Bhanu Pratap Seth must appear and show cause why proceedings should not be started against them for interference in the administration of justice. Batra must explain on affidavit why he was in the courtroom without a proper pass. The Court also requested Additional Advocate General Manish Goyal to be present.
Citing court security, the Court directed that litigants will not be allowed into courtrooms with mobile phones, and that advocates will be solely responsible if a client is found carrying one. The Registrar General must paste a notice to this effect at the pass counter. The Registrar (Protocol) must make sure litigants without proper passes are not allowed in and that passes carry an endorsement banning mobile phones in courtrooms.
The matter will be heard as a fresh case on November 20, 2026 at 10:00 am.
Case Title: Kuldeep Batra v. State of U.P. and Another
Case No.: Matters Under Article 227 No. 14284 of 2026
Bench: Justice Vikram D. Chauhan
Date: November 19, 2026
