FIR Naming Accused On Hearsay Cannot Supply Proof Witnesses Failed To Furnish At Trial: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that an FIR naming an accused on the basis of hearsay cannot make up for proof that witnesses failed to provide at trial. The Court acquitted a Haryana man convicted of murdering two widows in 2011, finding that the courts below had used police statements of hostile witnesses as substantive evidence, contrary to Section 162 CrPC.

A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed the appeals filed by Naresh. The appeals challenged a 2013 Punjab and Haryana High Court judgment that upheld his conviction but commuted his death sentence to life imprisonment, while acquitting his co-accused, Subhash @ Tinku.

Background

On the night of April 17, 2011, two widows, Suman and Shakuntla, were found dead at their houses near the Post Office chowk of village Ranila in Bhiwani district. The FIR was registered on the statement of a village panch, Kailash Chander. It named only Naresh, alleging that he had killed the women with a danda.

The trial court convicted both accused under Sections 302, 449, 297 and 201 IPC and sentenced them to death. The High Court acquitted Subhash. It upheld Naresh’s conviction, mainly because his name figured in the FIR, and commuted his sentence to life imprisonment.

All the private witnesses who could have spoken to the occurrence or to the involvement of the accused turned hostile at trial. These included the informant, Suman’s son (then about 8-9 years old), and the only adult said to have witnessed the incident.

Arguments

READ ALSO  Sanctity of the Institution of Marriage Taken for a Ride": Allahabad High Court Slams Fake Marriage Certificates

Counsel for the appellant argued that the conviction rested on no legally admissible evidence and that every vital link in the chain was missing. Counsel also submitted that the gandasi was recovered only through a second disclosure recorded after the post-mortem revealed incised wounds. Counsel pointed out that the reasons for acquitting Subhash applied equally to Naresh, who had been in custody since April 18, 2011.

Counsel for the State supported the concurrent findings. Counsel argued that the witnesses had resiled only because they were the appellant’s relatives or neighbours, and that the medical opinion connected the gandasi to the injuries.

Supreme Court’s Findings

The Court held that both courts below had used the previous statements as proof of their contents. It described this as “an error of law which strikes at the root of the conviction.” Even a proved contradiction only impeaches a witness’s credit, the Bench explained: “a proved contradiction may show that the witness is unreliable, but it cannot show that what he told the police is true.”

On the FIR, the Court noted that the informant was not an eyewitness and did not disclose his source. It held that his signature proved only that he made the statement, not the truth of what unnamed persons had told him. The Bench observed, “An FIR which names an accused on hearsay cannot supply the proof which the witnesses failed to furnish at the trial.”

The Court also explained that its ruling in Bhagwan Dass v. State (NCT of Delhi) cannot be read as allowing a hostile witness’s police statement to be treated as substantive evidence. It added that the Constitution Bench decision in Tahsildar Singh had not been brought to the notice of the Court in that case.

On the recoveries, the Court found that the disclosure statements were not proved in accordance with Section 27 of the Evidence Act, as the appellant’s actual words were never narrated in evidence. The danda had no connection with the fatal injuries, which were all incised and bone-deep. The second disclosure, naming a gandasi, was recorded after the post-mortem and was “in direct contradiction” to the first.

The Court noted that the High Court had rejected Subhash’s corresponding disclosure for exactly this reason. It called the High Court’s explanation, that both weapons were “possibly” used, “a conjecture and not a finding on evidence.”

The forensic report found the blood group inconclusive throughout. The blood on the gandasi could not even be shown to be human. The Court also held that the alleged motive rested on no admissible evidence. Applying the principle of parity, it said the evidence against both accused was “of the same kind and quality.”

Noting that the families had waited more than 15 years, the Court observed, “a conviction for murder must rest on evidence which the law admits and which proves guilt beyond reasonable doubt.”

Outcome

The Supreme Court set aside the conviction and sentence and acquitted Naresh of all charges. It directed his immediate release unless he is required in any other case. The compensation order under Section 357 CrPC was also set aside, and any fine deposited is to be refunded.

READ ALSO  कोई भी धर्म प्रदूषण को बढ़ावा नहीं देता: पटाखों पर प्रतिबंध के क्रियान्वयन में ढिलाई बरतने पर सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने दिल्ली पुलिस को फटकार लगाई

The Court recommended that the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, consider granting compensation to the legal representatives of Suman and Shakuntla under the applicable Victim Compensation Scheme.

Case Title: Naresh v. State of Haryana

Case No.: Criminal Appeal Nos. 1137-1138 of 2014

Bench: Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh

Date: November 16, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles