Written Exam Added After Advertisement Not Arbitrary Where Rules Allow “Competitive Examination/Selection”: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that adding a written examination to a recruitment process after the advertisement was issued does not make the selection arbitrary, where the governing rules provide for direct recruitment through “competitive examination/selection”. The Court dismissed an appeal by unsuccessful candidates challenging the recruitment of 46 Excise Constables in Nagaland, and upheld the Gauhati High Court’s Division Bench ruling.

A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar found no reason to interfere with the High Court’s judgment dated 23.06.2026.

Background of the Nagaland Excise Constable Recruitment

The Department of Excise and Prohibition, Government of Nagaland, issued an advertisement on 07.04.2025 inviting applications from indigenous inhabitants of the State for 40 Excise Constable posts, with Class VIII as the required qualification. Six more posts were added later, taking the total to 46. The recruitment was governed by the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999.

On 04.06.2025, the Departmental Recruitment Board issued a Corrigendum adding a written examination to the process. The Physical Test was held in July 2025. The written examination carried 100 marks, consisted of multiple-choice questions at the Class VIII standard, and was held on 09.08.2025.

READ ALSO  Primary Electronic Data Needs No Section 65B Certificate; Delhi High Court Upholds Conviction for Repeated Rape and Extortion

A Single Judge of the High Court allowed the candidates’ writ petition on 16.10.2025, quashing the Corrigendum and the Physical Test. The Division Bench reversed that ruling on the State’s appeal.

Arguments Before the Supreme Court

Advocate Diksha Rai, appearing for the appellants, argued that Clause 4 of the advertisement provided for only two stages: a Physical Test and a Suitability Test/Viva-Voce. Relying on the 1999 Rules and a Memorandum dated 19.07.2016 issued by the Commissioner of Excise and Prohibition, she contended that the selection criteria could not be altered once the process had begun.

Advocate General K.N. Balgopal, appearing for the State of Nagaland, pointed to the scale of the recruitment: 11,521 applications for 46 posts. He submitted that an objective written screening test was needed to reduce the large field of candidates. He also argued that most of the appellants had taken part in the process, including ten who sat for the written examination, and so could not challenge it afterwards.

READ ALSO  Allahabad High Court Orders Proceedings Against Staff for Unauthorized Conversion of Case Types

Supreme Court’s Findings on the Midway Written Exam

The Court noted that Rule 5(i)(a) of the 1999 Rules provides for direct recruitment through “competitive examination/selection”. It held that “the written examination, based on the Class VIII syllabus, falls under “competitive examination/selection” within the meaning of Rule 5(i)(a)”, so the requirement to consult the Commission before adopting a different method was not attracted.

On the 2016 Memorandum, the Court agreed with the Division Bench that it had neither been confirmed by the Selection Board nor notified by the State, had not been strictly enforced in earlier recruitments, and at most prescribed certain minimum physical and medical standards. The Court also noted that Clauses 15 and 16 of the advertisement empowered the Board to rectify omissions through notifications and to take final decisions on disputes.

The Court rejected the argument that the written test was arbitrary because it was introduced later or carried 100 marks against 12 for the viva-voce. It observed that “an objective written examination, based on the already-prescribed Class VIII standard, provides a means of assessing candidates on a common basis and avoids placing disproportionate reliance on the comparatively subjective assessment inherent in a Viva-Voce.”

The Bench noted that the Corrigendum was widely publicised, including in local newspapers, and that all candidates who cleared the Physical Test faced the same requirement. It held: “The appellants have not been able to demonstrate how the process operated discriminatorily or caused any prejudice to them as admittedly having participated in the selection process despite being aware of the revised procedure.”

Outcome

READ ALSO  Allahabad HC Upholds Transfer Policy of Assistant Teachers in Basic Education, Says Transfer is Not Matter of Right

Citing “the discretion available to the competent recruiting authority in devising selection/shortlisting procedures where the applicable Rules do not prescribe a detailed method”, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal.

Case Title: T. Akon Phom and Others v. State of Nagaland and Others

Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 14203 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 22477 of 2026)

Bench: Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar

Date: 16.11.2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles