The Malappuram District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed Central Railway to pay Rs 25,000 to a law student whose train ticket was automatically cancelled after its reservation status changed from RAC 44 to Waiting List 1. The commission held that cancelling the ticket without prior intimation or a satisfactory explanation, while also deducting clerkage charges from the refund, amounted to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.
In its August 17 order, the commission awarded Rs 20,000 as compensation and Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses. It also found that the Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation (IRCTC) could not be held responsible for the cancellation because its role was restricted to providing an online ticket-booking platform.
The commission, comprising President Mohandasan K and Members Preethi Sivaraman C and Mohamed Ismayil CV, passed the order on a complaint concerning an emergency journey from Mumbai to Malappuram in Kerala.
Commission Examines Cancellation and Additional Travel Expenses
The complainant, a student of KC Law College in Mumbai, had booked a railway ticket through the IRCTC application to return to Kerala because of an emergency.
According to his complaint, the ticket initially showed RAC 44 as its current reservation status. However, the status subsequently changed to Waiting List 1, and the ticket was automatically cancelled.
The student maintained that the unexpected cancellation forced him to purchase another ticket at a higher fare to travel on the same train. He also challenged the deduction of Rs 65 as clerkage charges from the refund, arguing that the circumstances leading to the cancellation were beyond his control.
The commission observed that the cancellation had caused inconvenience during an emergency journey and imposed an additional financial burden because the complainant had to make a fresh booking.
It also considered the student’s contention that neither the Railways nor IRCTC had adequately explained why his reservation status had changed.
Railways and IRCTC Defend Reservation Process
Advocate Krishna Kumar KM, representing Central Railway, submitted that an RAC ticket did not amount to a confirmed berth reservation before preparation of the final chart. According to the Railway Board and IRCTC guidelines, the availability of accommodation determined whether an RAC passenger would receive a berth.
The Railways denied having any policy for downgrading tickets and defended the deduction of clerkage charges as a standard procedure applicable uniformly to passengers.
IRCTC, represented by Advocate Jaison Thomas, maintained that ticket sales through its online platform constituted its limited responsibility. Matters involving berth allotment, preparation of reservation charts, automatic cancellation of waitlisted tickets and refund regulations were handled by the Railways.
IRCTC submitted that the complainant’s booking initially carried Waiting List number 77 and remained at Waiting List number 1 after chart preparation. Consequently, no berth was allotted.
It further pointed out that the Railways’ PNR status facility cautioned passengers that reservation status could improve or deteriorate before final chart preparation.
IRCTC also relied on its website’s terms and conditions, which clarified that it did not guarantee the allotment of a particular coach or berth.
RTI Replies and Ticket Records Considered
While examining the documents, the commission found that the complainant’s e-ticket initially recorded WL 77 as the booking status and RAC 44 as the current status.
Subsequent records showed that although the original booking status remained WL 77, the current status had changed to WL 1 before preparation of the chart. The final record reflected the ticket as cancelled.
The commission also examined information obtained through the Right to Information Act.
In response to a question about whether an RAC ticket permitted travel, the Railways had confirmed that an RAC passenger could travel with sitting accommodation.
Another RTI response revealed that a 3A coach had been replaced with a 3E coach for unavoidable reasons and that confirmed passengers had been accommodated in the replacement coach.
The commission further considered a communication from Railway customer support stating that some coaches had been detached from the train due to operational feasibility, resulting in changes to reservation status.
These records were examined alongside the complainant’s assertion that he had to purchase a fresh ticket on the same train after his original reservation was cancelled.
Central Railway Held Liable, IRCTC Exonerated
After considering the evidence and submissions, the commission concluded that Central Railway was responsible for the deficiency in service and unfair trade practice arising from the cancellation of the complainant’s ticket.
It directed the Railways to pay Rs 20,000 in compensation for the inconvenience and hardship suffered by the student, together with Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.
However, the commission did not find IRCTC liable, accepting that the corporation operated the online reservation platform and did not control berth allocation, chart preparation or automatic cancellation of tickets.
